7 ms·
It amazes me how the Reality Distortion Field is strong. The Droid came with a 265 ppi screen and very few people cared (maybe http://xkcd.com/662 http://xkcd.c
by rglullis 16y ago
It amazes me how the Reality Distortion Field is strong. The Droid came with a 265 ppi screen and very few people cared (maybe http://xkcd.com/662 http://xkcd.com/662 ). I googled around and could not find people taking pictures to compare the Droid screen with the iPhone 3GS screen.
(Also, I'd love to find reviews of critics about the "squared, industrial" design on the Droid and their opinions on the "squared, industrial" designed iPhone. But I digress.)
If anything, this seems to be how there's a void of real game-changing things on the iPhone 4, and yet bloggers and the writers who depend on Apple hype are working much harder to find anything to sell.
- bmalicoat 16y agoI think the main reasons this is getting more press is because the resolution is over the ~300 ppi barrier that makes most eyes unable to resolve pixels. The square design of the iPhone 4 is functional (try balancing a 3GS on its side to do a video call...), so whether you like the design or not it is a necessity.
- ergo98 16y ago>I think the main reasons this is getting more press is because the resolution is over the ~300 ppi barrier that makes most eyes unable to resolve pixels. Ugh. Tell me you don't actually believe that? The resolution of the iPhone 4 was predetermined to simply pixel-double existing iPhone applications (no sloppy scaling or black-bordered apps for the legacy stockpile). It is only marginally denser than several Android phones, and is a big ball of WGAF wrapped in ridiculous market speak. It's great that they increased the resolution to be more competitive with most other high end smartphones, but the retina stuff is such a stretch of nonsense.
- bmalicoat 16y agoWell, it is certainly easier for devs that they pixel doubled, but I don't think the resolution is hyperbole, see: http://mblogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/2010/06/10/resolving-the-iphone-resolution/ http://mblogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/2010/06/10/r...
- mediaman 16y agoHey. You seem like a pretty smart guy. Throughout your comments on this thread, though, you've demonstrated a level of condescension, arrogance, and rudeness that is inappropriate for civil dialog between people (see also your comment elsewhere, "the ignorance is incredible"). Your intelligent input would be valued much more highly were you able to rephrase your commentary to show respect for others, even if you know they are wrong. See http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html ; specifically, the first two lines under the subheading In Comments.
- loewenskind 16y agoWhat indication do you have that this person is "pretty smart"? They are obviously blinded by Apple hate and spewing nonsense that's been rebutted in this thread. A "pretty smart" person would be happy that iPhone has on-upped all the competitors. Does the GP think that e.g. Android is going to say "well darn, looks like they made something better. Time to quit"? Of course they will come out with something to compete. As someone said elsewhere in the thread: this is a win for us. We should be happy that iPhone is pushing the envelope just as we should be happy that they changed the game to begin with. You don't have to like them or use them to benefit from their technology.
- antipaganda 16y agoCalling him smart was to try to get him to read the rest.
- ergo98 16y ago>They are obviously blinded by Apple hate and spewing nonsense that's been rebutted in this thread. Does this make you feel smart? I don't hate Apple at all. What I do hate, however, is when reality is rewritten, North Korea style, to favor Apple's great stewardship. It is an incredible offense to anyone with any common sense or actual knowledge. But hey, did you hear that the iPhone invented video calling? It's the first to do it right. Am I right?
- 16y ago
- Tichy 16y agoWhich is probably just clever marketing by Apple. Doesn't it always depend on how far away from your eyes you hold the phone?
- cheald 16y agoYes, precisely. I can't visually resolve pixels on my 42" 52 PPI TV at a normal viewing distance. I can't resolve pixels on my Nexus One at my normal operating distance unless I look really hard (252 PPI), but I tend to hold it ~12-18 inches away.
- fh 16y agoOf course, but the 10-12 inches they quote as normal operating distance is pretty reasonable as far as I'm concerned. So while clever marketing, I wouldn't call it false advertising.
- cmelbye 16y agoDing ding ding, we have a winner. Clever marketing. If you're wondering why people care so much, it's the MARKETING! I bet if I asked 10 non-geeks what a Nexus One was, at least half would have no idea what I'm talking about.
- tumult 16y agoThe panel used on the Droid is of the TN kind, so the viewing angle is nowhere near as good as the iPhone 4 -- the perspective difference between your left and right eye is also enough to make the screen appear different to each, which makes it harder to look at and resolve detail. The iPhones up until 4 are all like this, too, which is one of the reasons why the difference between them is so striking. The Droid is a cheap plastic gizmo. Two of my friends have had theirs slowly break from everyday use. If you have to baby your gadget, it will never really break into the mainstream and make a difference. (I still like AMOLED more.)
- rglullis 16y agoI never noticed the difference in perspective you are talking about, but still: what about the screen from the Nexus One? Same resolution as the Droid, ~250 ppi and AMOLED. Yeah, one can find "Oh, shiny!" articles about it, but no one wanted to turn that into a absolutely remarkable feature. As for the Droid quality: I bought mine in November and it's still going. Dropped it a couple of times (what caused a tiny crack on the corner, can't even see it if I don't point it out) and the keyboard "right-alt" key forces me sometimes to press it twice. I wouldn't say that the phone will outlive me, but it is far from being a "cheap plastic gizmo".
- modeless 16y agoI don't know; people were pretty excited about the AMOLED screen. The excitement was tempered, however, by the fact that it's useless in daylight. Also, people liked the industrial design of the Droid. Take this quote from Engadget's review: "an industrial design straight from a gadget enthusiast's fever-dream"; and this: "they've made a device which is truly lustworthy, even next to the best efforts of Apple, HTC, and Palm."
- cheald 16y agoSpeaking as a Nexus One owner, it's not quite useless, it's just harder to use. Froyo's automatic brightness adjustment makes it quite usable in direct sunlight, though it's obviously not going to compete with an LCD. However, the display is just beyond gorgeous, and given that I work very hard to stay _out_ of the sun, it's a great fit for me.
- cakesy 16y agoFirstly, which droid? There are at least 2. I have heard good things about the nexus screen, and also bad things, because of the unique pixel placement. Maybe blame the manufacturers for not talking about the droids PPI, whereas Apple has made it a major talking point. This is why this is such a big issue. And talking about the reality distortion field just makes you sound ignorant. A lot of people like Apple because they produce great hardware and software, so they trust them. Other companies have had such trust and blown it.
- karzeem 16y agoAnother thing is that the number of pixels increases as the square of the ppi, so a 326 ppi screen has 51% more pixels than a 265 ppi screen. That's a bigger difference than a person might think from just comparing ppi.
- ugh 16y agoDroid and Nexus were widely praised for their displays, the displays were mentioned whenever anyone wrote anything about the phones. Seeing how the iPhone now has a substantially higher resolution and a ISP screen, it getting praise seems to me to be pretty normal.
- zmmmmm 16y agoThe difference between a Nexus and a 3gs is way bigger than between a iphone 4 and a nexus. I remember telling lots of iPhone folks how much difference it made to have such high resolution on the N1 and they all said "meh ... it's good enough, who cares to have more?" Now it seems to be the only thing that matters ...
- ugh 16y agoIt was widely praised for that. Everywhere! Enthusiastically! Just because you talked to some people who are obviously idiots …
- Tichy 16y agoWhat amuses me is that before the iPhone 4, iPhone users insisted that the iPhone resolution is perfect and no higher resolution was necessary. Now suddenly they would never ever consider buying a phone with less resolution.
- Yaggo 16y agoSince when have users known what they want? (Have to admit, I'm exactly one of those.)
- ugh 16y agoUhm, source? Many have called the old screen great but that’s not the same as saying that improvement is impossible or undesirable.
- dieterrams 16y agoWhat amuses me is how threatened people can get by a photo of a phone, that they have to start insulting people for their appreciation of it.
- Tichy 16y agoinsulting?
- dieterrams 16y ago> (Also, I'd love to find reviews of critics about the "squared, industrial" design on the Droid and their opinions on the "squared, industrial" designed iPhone. But I digress.) I think you might be confusing an industrial look with industrial design. The latter is a practice, not a style. The Droid has a more squared, industrial look. iPhone 4 has a more squared industrial design relative to its predecessors, but not so much an industrial look.
- zokier 16y agoWell, you wouldn't happen to have a comparable picture of the droid at hand?