4 ms·
SpaceX Dragon capsule can't land without atmosphere either it needs it to aerobreak it doesn't carry nearly enough fuel to come to a rest from orbital reentry s
by dogma1138 10y ago
SpaceX Dragon capsule can't land without atmosphere either it needs it to aerobreak it doesn't carry nearly enough fuel to come to a rest from orbital reentry speeds using propulsion alone.
- ceejayoz 10y agohttps://www.quora.com/Can-the-Dragon-V2-land-on-the-moon https://www.quora.com/Can-the-Dragon-V2-land-on-the-moon > The Dragon-2 has enough power and fuel to land and ascend back to lunar orbit. The Dragon's SuperDraco has higher performance than the Apollo Lunar Module. Apollo LM descent engines has 10,000 lbf thrust, and 3,500 lbf thrust for ascent (the lander part is left behind). The Dragon's SuperDraco has 16,000 lbf thrust. The Dragon also uses computers to control throttle and land (much more fuel efficient). Hence, the Dragon-2 has enough power and fuel to land and ascend back to lunar orbit even if it carries all it's parts during ascent. However, it may need to cut crew from 7 to 3 to loose more weight for fuel. (Plus, I said "more SpaceX" as in "capsules with powered descent", not "SpaceX's exact current models as already implemented"...)
- dogma1138 10y agoLunar orbit isn't earth reentry tho, even the SuperDraco doesn't seem to carry enough fuel nor have the specific impulse for an earth landing when you remove the aerobreaking.
- ceejayoz 10y agoOK? I'm not sure what point you're trying to make, then, as there's not a no-atmosphere, Earth-sized body in the solar system for your argument to apply to.
- mapt 10y agoThat is not accurate. Estimates are that the Dragon v2 has about 400m/s dV. This is around what it would need for controlled landing or abort. It takes around 1720m/s just to get to the stationary Lunar surface from Lunar orbit; If a Falcon upper stage detaches during the leg of the mission between Earth and Luna, the necessary delta V for the rest of the mission will be around 5080m/s. This is a lot. You would have to build another fairly large vehicle to accomplish this mission - Dragon v2 would be an afterthought.
- taneq 10y agoI don't understand how they can conclude that "the Dragon-2 has enough power and fuel to land and ascend back to lunar orbit" based only on a comparison of maximum thrust and a statement that the Dragon has an automated landing system. At the very least, they'd need to consider the dry weight and fuel load to make a fair comparison - maybe they did so offscreen but it's not mentioned anywhere in the post.
- kobeya 10y agoBecause it was a design requirement of the Dragon. It was designed to do that.
- zardo 10y agoIt definitely was not designed to de-orbit and land on the moon. It has nowhere near enough dV to do that. Maybe it has been designed to work as a technology platform for deriving a lunar lander. But the Dragon 2 design is just not capable of doing it, not even close.