4 ms·
> The process is still young so it's imperfect, but improving. Do you have any suggestions how I can do better? Publish your book list, your selection process,
by throwanem 10y ago
> The process is still young so it's imperfect, but improving. Do you have any suggestions how I can do better?
Publish your book list, your selection process, and your metrics, to enable independent evaluation. I looked for such information and didn't find it; if it's there, surface it clearly. If you're presenting the balanced, apolar perspective you claim to seek, rather than some flavor of "alternative facts", this should not pose an issue, I think.
As for the rest, I wouldn't feel special about it. In these times, I see no reason why anyone claiming political
motives, and apparently declining any meaningful transparency in sources and methods, merits any kind of credibility. Your claims are your claims, and prove nothing beyond that you've made them. You have an opportunity to substantiate them. Perhaps you will do so.
- m52go 10y agoYou're right to be skeptical. I noted elsewhere in the thread that I plan to open access to that information when it makes sense. This is a weekend project and I really didn't expect this much attention this soon! But you made me realize just how important this issue really is. So I just added a Transparency section (link on very bottom of main page) with the titles of all books currently in the system, along with a link to a public Google Form showing all suggestions and how they were handled. I was using Typeform before but results were private. It's not as thorough as what you had in mind, but I'll put that in place over time.
- throwanem 10y agoAn excellent and amply satisfactory initial response.