6 ms·
This op ed is non-sensical. According to the author, every successful startup in history is "cancer". Wikipedia's costs have grown because their usage has grown
by hn_throwaway_99 10y ago
This op ed is non-sensical. According to the author, every successful startup in history is "cancer". Wikipedia's costs have grown because their usage has grown exponentially (comparing costs to economy-wide inflation is particularly baffling).
If anything, I got from this article that Wikipedia has kept costs well below revenue growth, which is normally the sign of a healthy organization.
- microcolonel 10y agoIf you read the article, you'll notice it says that the expenses are growing faster than the traffic, and faster than revenue. This is the exact opposite of what you would normally expect (due to economies of scale).
- openasocket 10y agoThe table of spending vs. revenue suggests revenue is growing just as fast as expenses. There's nothing here about the trends of the amount of traffic over time. And if there was, the cost of hosting and developing a system vs the amount of traffic is can take is not a linear relationship.
- microcolonel 10y ago> There's nothing here about the trends of the amount of traffic over time. Yes there is. 2005: > So, we're doing around 1.4 billion page views monthly. 2016: > According to the WMF, Wikipedia (in all language editions) now receives 16 billion page views per month.
- openasocket 10y agoMy mistake. What about revenue, though? It looks to be growing as fast as expenses if not faster
- microcolonel 10y agoThe version of the article on the signpost lacks the table of figures, if you go to the version on his user page, it paints a clearer picture [0]. idorosen has posted a table on the root thread which adds a column for the expense ratio (1 minus the margin) and it's getting much higher much quicker [1]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_Cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_C... [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14287495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14287495
- openasocket 10y agoidrosen is pretty clear these numbers aren't that scary, though.
- microcolonel 10y agoWell, try to draw a trend line through the operating margin and tell me it's not that scary. I think that it's pretty scary if your permanent, ongoing financial commitments are growing to match your revenues. This way, you have no cash to react to intermittent expenses or R&D. And let's remember that Wikipedia is already doing more donation drives than ever.
- lr4444lr 10y agoSuccinct and correct. I have been a regular donor to Wikipedia for years now, because I use the service heavily, support its mission, and like the access I have to contribute to its vast body of knowledge. When the fundraising solicitations come around, I've typically been too busy to look into the financials and have always assumed they operated at near costs and had declining revenue. Now, perhaps Wikipedia has some unfortunate but real problems around editorializing, and they have to pay a growing army to keep the worst of the forces of troll-dom at bay with conscientious hired curatorial help. Otherwise, I see no other reason why they should have 300X the employees. This is eye-opening, to say the least.
- apsec112 10y agoWikipedia staff don't edit content, fix pages, warn trolls, or ban vandals. That's all volunteer labor.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAnd this is exactly the issue. Fund raising got to be "too" successful, which is to say at some point WMF did a fundraising round and they had more money than they needed, and rather than give that money back they spent it. And the next year, what ever it was they spent it on (could have been salaries or perks or what ever) seemed like "of course we need that thing we did it last year" and so they targeted to raise the higher amount, but they over shot again, and then spent more. This has been a trap for charitable organizations ever since they existed. Churches, clubs, museums, Etc. The second trap is embezzlement which happens all the time because, as a donation funded organization for some reason people often neglect strong financial controls. The article author is correct that unless corrected, this situation will kill the Wikimedia Foundation.
- lern_too_spel 10y agoSupporting many more languages and new projects like news and structured data should require more individual contributors and a corresponding management structure. Then of course you need HR to manage them, a fundraising organization that gets money from all over the world, and yet more people to handle the finances that have now gotten complicated. To me, it's a no-brainer that the WMF of today needs more than one employee. Whether it needs 300, I don't know, but that doesn't sound far enough off for me to quibble with them over it.
- Animats 10y agoIf hosting cost per hit has increased, something is wrong. Computer costs have gone down since 2005. That's worth looking into. Wikipedia hasn't gone down the Web 2.0 Javascript/CSS rathole, where every page loads megabytes of vaguely useful junk. What's the problem?
- fictioncircle 10y agoThe OP is complaining about personnel and fundraising costs rather than actual hosting costs.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- roryisok 10y agoAnd thank heavens for that. Imagine medium style resource bloat every time you want to read about how Rasputin died
- vacri 10y agoImproved high availability and geographic dispersion. They're running in multiple datacenters across the globe now.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> If hosting cost per hit has increased, something is wrong. Computer costs have gone down since 2005. Images are dramatically larger, both in the raw size out of cameras and the resolutions people are willing to put on pages (including higher-DPI screens). Video's likely a lot more prevalent now, too. I dunno what they're paying for bandwidth, but AWS S3 has barely dropped per-GB bandwidth costs since its release in 2006.
- Arizhel 10y ago>Images are dramatically larger, both in the raw size out of cameras and the resolutions people are willing to put on pages (including higher-DPI screens). That shouldn't be a big problem. Screen resolutions have not increased significantly in years (most desktops and laptops are still stuck with 1920x1080), so there's no reason for larger images at all. It should be trivial to write the software so that it auto-scales the image down to an appropriate size for web display on modern screens (which is small, since most Wikipedia images are pretty small within the text, just like any reference work), while also providing a clickable link to allow seeing the image at full resolution. Very few visitors are going to view any image in an article at full resolution, let alone all the images in the article, so the only thing growing should be the image sizes of those optional full-size images. Even there, the software can compress the raw images down to well-compressed JPEGs; it's not Wikipedia's job to store unedited, low or no-compression raw images; an 80% quality JPEG is sufficient. Same goes for videos; that stuff can be compressed, scaled, recoded to more efficient codecs, etc.
- sillysaurus3 10y agoIn 2005, Wikipedia co-founder and Wikimedia Foundation founder Jimmy Wales told a TED audience: > So, we're doing around 1.4 billion page views monthly. So, it's really gotten to be a huge thing. And everything is managed by the volunteers and the total monthly cost for our bandwidth is about US$5,000, and that's essentially our main cost. We could actually do without the employee … We actually hired Brion because he was working part-time for two years and full-time at Wikipedia so we actually hired him so he could get a life and go to the movies sometimes. According to the WMF, Wikipedia (in all language editions) now receives 16 billion page views per month. The WMF spends roughly US$2 million a year on Internet hosting and employs some 300 staff. The modern Wikipedia hosts 11–12 times as many pages as it did in 2005, but the WMF is spending 33 times as much on hosting, has about 300 times as many employees, and is spending 1,250 times as much overall. WMF's spending has gone up by 85% over the past three years.
- muninn_ 10y agoNo real reason to think that the costs scale linearly. Maybe you need 300 employees to maintain the site at that scale?
- eropple 10y ago> Maybe you need 300 employees to maintain the site at that scale? Should you? I mean, my day job is making it so you expressly don't. If your costs are scaling even linearly I would say you're doing something wrong. The point of scaling is to reduce costs--economies of scale are why you scale. And a user-editable encyclopedia and PHP application are not really good arguments for diseconomies.
- muninn_ 10y agoBut you can't reach perfect efficiency. Scaling will of course reduce costs in general, but it's not a given. If I had an app that had 5 users, my costs would increase if my user number grew to 5,000,000,000. Without knowing more information about the financials, or how resources are allocated this is all conjecture. But a website that services 17bb page views/month is going to cost a lot of money to run. They could be spending their money very poorly, idk, but I also don't know whether or not what they are spending is an appropriate amount.
- ealexhudson 10y agoBut he's right: every successful startup in history is cancer. Deliberately so: they grow huge very, very quickly. It's steroids. The trick with any great start up is how to get out of the "aggressive growth without revenue" stage. Some (very few) keep the growth but aggressively grow revenue and become self-sustaining. Others dial down the growth at a certain stage, and revenue increases to match, and they're self-sustaining. The point is you have to become sustainable. Most start-ups flare out badly. You cannot change over-night from "growth like cancer" to "stable and flat". You need some way to switch and it takes time.
- openasocket 10y agoBut, according to the table, they have more revenue than expenses and revenue is growing just as fast if not faster than expenses.
- akolbe 10y agoYes, and that revenue comes from begging banners that more often than not create the - entirely false - impression that if people don't donate, Wikipedia will blink out of existence. In the early days, when almost everything was volunteer-run, hosting costs were indeed Wikipedia's main expense (as explained in that old quote from Jimmy Wales). These days, hosting amounts to about 2% of expenses, and most of the rest goes to staff costs (incl. about two dozen people in fundraising alone). Meanwhile, most of the value - the actual content - is contributed by unpaid volunteers. The paid staff have absolutely nothing to do with it. Nobody minded working for free when there was just enough money to cover hosting costs. Now, however, there is an influx of $100 million in donations a year, and none of that benefits the average contributor, the people actually writing Wikipedia. That grates a little, much like in the monkey fairness experiment (Google it if you're unfamiliar with it).
- Negitivefrags 10y agoTo be honest, most successful startups are indeed quite cancerous. Twitter doesn't need 3,500 employees, Facebook doesn't need 17,000 and Google doesn't need 72,000. They could all fire 50%-90% of their workforce and the product wouldn't be materially affected for the vast majority of users. The reason they have this many is because they can have this many. Their success has given food to the cancerous growth. You get this situation whenever a company isn't operated by a shareholder who get's dividends. When the person who runs the company knows that every dollar they don't spend is money in their pocket, people start to actually care about expenses and only focusing on what is important.
- ec109685 10y agoThere isn't any basis to your statement that Facebook could make as much short term and long term profit if they fired half their staff. Instagram, for instance, is much bigger than they were a couple years ago, and those employees have built things that have drove growth for the product.
- eropple 10y agoYou don't even have to go as far as the big tech companies. You see it even in smaller ones. Something that's stuck with me is when, in the span of about a week or so, I had multiple people at different startups answer a question "hey, how's it going?" with "oh, really great, we [note: not founders] just closed a round and we're hiring X more people [note: at companies where the product is stable and well-understood]". It's fief-building, to a large extent.
- ashark 10y agoI agree that a lot of tech companies have a much larger staff than they need (especially the mid sized ones) and I agree that Google in particular seems to suffer from severe mismanagement, but this is kind of the best case when you see a company with high enough barriers to entry that they collect rents: they spend on R&D and other "wasteful" stuff. Part of the problem with the thought experiment of the perfect free market (infinite producers/consumers) is that margins are so razor thin that no one can do this kind of stuff, which can be enormously beneficial when well coordinated (see: postwar Japan) so you do want some of it to happen.
- dalbasal 10y agoI'd say that's a little strong. You're right that the costs of running wikipedia are still quite low considering the incredible scope, popularity and importance of the site. "Cancer" seems over the top and needlessly combative. But, it definitely doesn't hurt having someone bring up the fact that costs grew by 6x in 6 years. As he says, more years of this could put wikipedia in a precarious position. It seems the OP cares about wikipedia and is genuinely worried. These conversations need to be had (also at fast growing startups) and having them in the open is part of the wikipedia way. Maybe he's wrong but it doesn't seem nonsensical or disingenuous to me. It seems genuine and rational.
- smacktoward 10y agoWikipedia is an explicitly not-for-profit enterprise, and thus something completely different from the standard startup. For most startups, success means getting bought out by a larger company. Wikipedia by contrast has always put the highest priority on maintaining its own independence, which means that for them a buyout would be a profound failure.
- watwut 10y agoWell, most startups fail. (For various reasons)
- Waterluvian 10y agoMy first thought was, "there's no way Wikipedia still only needs $5000 per month for bandwidth"
- erikb 10y agoWhat you say is correct. He just says something different and not the opposite. He talks about that a money hungry, fast growing business is not the model an open content wiki should have as a foundation. The value to the user would probably be the same if it would be a 3 person inc with $150k/year revenue.
- jlawer 10y agoI think the article was questioning if this is suitable for a Charity. A business should be able to estimate its growth and sales, and can re-invent itself if a path isn't going to be profitable. The growth in a business should also be growing revenue (or it should be creating the foundation for later revenue). A charity is based on how much people are willing to donate, which can change VERY quickly. Imagine what would happen if the public perception of the people behind wikipedia was to dramatically change and next fundraising campaign only brought in 20% of last years? Additionally If people start to believe that the finances are squandered or not spent as expected, there could be a movement to NOT donate. This happened with the Red Cross after 9/11 where people felt they were duped by the fact their donations went to a consolidated funds (often to fund overseas activities) rather exclusively to 9/11 victims. Charities also tend to need to keep a few years of funding in the bank to deal with a change in markets, as a charity typically can't use debt to get through rough years (economic downturns / recessions). Exponential growth makes this nearly impossible unless your running extremely lean. I think the article is a little sensationalist (and maybe it needed to be to reach certain people), it seems to have some sound concerns.