4 ms·
He thinks that NoSQL is not a very good name for the new databases we’re seeing these days, so he proposed a new name: postmodern databases. Why postmodern? We
by petercooper 16y ago
He thinks that NoSQL is not a very good name for the new databases we’re seeing these days, so he proposed a new name: postmodern databases. Why postmodern?
We've had similar points raised before, yet the term "NoSQL" continues to gain in popularity. There were similar concerns around "AJAX" and "Web 2.0" - both survived and are only just starting to be replaced.
Community-coined terms like NoSQL, AJAX, and Web 2.0 start as literal, descriptive terms. But after a while they become "brands" that represent a myriad of concepts and ideas that do not necessarily fit into their original definition. This is because they're not controlled or maintained by a single entity (like, say, "brands" like Redis, Twitter, Ruby or Django are).
(BTW, PomoDB would be a cool name for a new "NoSQL" database system ;-))
- thisduck 16y agoPomoDB looks awfully a lot like PornoDB, depending on the font you're using. Or depending on your mindset.
- petercooper 16y agoAh, so that explains why the "pomodoro" technique took off in some developer circles recently.. :-)
- jrockway 16y agoPornoDB is the database that captures snapshots of what happens on the Couch.
- pierrefar 16y agoAnd let's not talk about "replication" in PornoDB.
- wglb 16y agoOr something about tomatoes.
- wglb 16y agoOr something about tomatoes.
- amalcon 16y agoI still haven't figured out what Web 2.0 is supposed to be. The closest I've been able to figure is that it's either a pure buzzword, or synonymous with DHTML. If NoSQL goes the way of AJAX, that's fine. It's not a very good term, but at least it means something useful. If it goes the way of Web 2.0, no thanks -- I'd much prefer a different term, any different term, so long as it's actually descriptive.
- jerf 16y agoWeb 2.0 can't be synonymous with DHTML, the buzzwords are temporally separated by about ten years. DHMTL was what Netscape called its <layer> tag, before it got blown out of the water by IE 4's radically superior .innerHTML. (And I use "radically" carefully; it rewrote the web as we thought we knew it.)
- SkyMarshal 16y agoWeb 2.0 = Ajax + Social Media, basically. Websites that don't have to refresh the entire page to conduct user interaction, plus social news/networking/blogging/etc.
- petercooper 16y agoDon't forget gradients and rounded corners..
- dkarl 16y agoTwo more meanings of Web 2.0 to add to the mix: 1. A functional app with a modern, attractive design, as opposed to a legacy app that feels clunky and old. This is how it's used by non-technical people at my job. A web site can be made Web 2.0 by updating its aesthetics. Fixing bugs also makes it feel more Web 2.0. 2. A site where users can add "content" that can be seen by other users. This is how it's used by non-technical folks on campus, according to a friend of mine. Sounds reasonable, but it turns out they apply the definition quite literally, so any site with forums or comments is Web 2.0.
- bobbyi 16y agoWeb 2.0 isn't "community-coined". The term was invented by Tim O'Reilly to sell conference registrations and books. It's no more of a "brand name" and no more nebulous now than it was when he coined it. AJAX was coined by Jesse James Garrett. I'm not sure that he would consider himself to be a community.
- petercooper 16y agoYep, that's what I meant. AJAX was "community coined" in the sense that it was coined a member of the tech community, not by a company (as with a trademark or commercial brand name) or a standards body (as with official standards like "ECMAScript"). It's like when "the neighborhood" forms a "neighborhood watch." Not everyone in the neighborhood spontaneously starts it - it's usually one or a few people who come up with the idea and then everyone gels around it. Or like how Java was a technology created by Sun, even though it was really Patrick Naughton - it's a synecdoche of sorts. All that said, while the above stands for AJAX, you probably have a point regarding "Web 2.0" since it was tied to O'Reilly as a company via trademark, though I'd argue that the community essentially "stole" this brand and made it a lot of things that it never originally was.
- chromatic 16y agoVery minor nit: Dale Dougherty suggested "Web 2.0", not Tim.
- Groxx 16y agoI think NoSQL will probably out-last other names. It's got everything a geek wants: * Short (5 letters) * Opinionated (No) * TLA (SQL) (bonus points because it's well known)
- s-phi-nl 16y agoSeems to be an example of semantic diffusion. http://martinfowler.com/bliki/SemanticDiffusion.html http://martinfowler.com/bliki/SemanticDiffusion.html