4 ms·
"Understanding" is a subjective human concept, and not worth pursuing." Isn't human understanding of how our environment works precisely how you're able to sit
by bamboozled 10y ago
"Understanding" is a subjective human concept, and not worth pursuing."
Isn't human understanding of how our environment works precisely how you're able to sit in your chair and write comments on HN for others to read?
- cercatrova 10y agoSure but I might say that if I were to create a chair by generative methods, would I need to understand how it was created for it to be useful?
- bamboozled 10y agoIf you have ever crafted a chair, table, or anything else that is built by craftsperson, you will soon realise why such a profession exists, because it's very difficult. You might slap a few pieces of wood together and by brute force, create something like a chair and that might do, but it's very unlikely to be a good, safe, attractive, comfortable long lasting chair. Building quality furniture is complex and difficult work which takes a lot of skill, experience and understanding in order to do. I understand your point, I never said there is anything wrong with experimenting with NNs, I just don't agree with the OPs sentiment.
- backpropaganda 10y agoNo. Tools enabled it, not understanding.
- j2kun 10y agoGive one specific example of a widespread modern invention that did not require any understanding to create. You personally can use a tool without understanding how it's made, but you seem to claim the tools are invented without anyone's understanding.
- backpropaganda 10y agoNoone understands quantum mechanics. It's a bunch of equations or tools that provide predictive power. OMG, the scientism in this community is disgusting.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoNoone understands quantum mechanics but you will tell this scientistic community what quantum mechanics is, because you know what it is even if noone understands it. Sorry you're being downvoted but you're the one who's just throwing buzzwords around that you poorly understand. That's the definition of scientism, right there.
- backpropaganda 10y agoI don't understand QM, and no self-respecting physicist claims to understand it either. The consensus is pretty strong on this. QM is strange, the Standard Model is strange, but it works. I'm kinda surprised people like you are not aware of this simple fact. We don't live in 1700s anymore, and aren't in the world of high-school physics. Things are strange now, and the data-backed equations have replaced understanding. I can understand that people want science to explain things, but that's simply not the reality any more.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoOK, seriously. How are you in a position to know what is the consensus among quantum phycisists, or anything much about quantum mechanics? Are you a quantum phycisist? A soft eng at CERN? And what exactly do you mean "people like me"? Please don't do that.
- backpropaganda 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]