6 ms·
But seeming to seem is not the same as seeming, so you can't hold both to be true simultaneously. This whole thread had been about whether seeming actually happ
by naasking 10y ago
But seeming to seem is not the same as seeming, so you can't hold both to be true simultaneously. This whole thread had been about whether seeming actually happens at all. For instance, I've consistently stated that experience doesn't really exist, that it's an illusion, and so p-zombies can't exist. As I said earlier, I acknowledge I have "consciousness", but this doesn't necessarily entail the same set of properteies you expect. I am totally behind the idea that consciousness is an informational property, but that hasn't been the impression I've gotten from your posts.
- monktastic1 10y agoBut seeming to seem is a form of seeming. And the only form of illusion I know of requires seeming: things seem one way but are actually another. I simply do not understand what it means to doubt or deny that it seems like something is happening (though it's perfectly clear to me what it means to doubt that something is actually happening). When I see (and even accept) a proof of it, will I say "well it sure seems like something is happening, but I'm wrong, so it doesn't really seem like anything is happening?" Perhaps my imagination is limited. I thank you for trying!
- naasking 10y ago> But seeming to seem is a form of seeming. And the only form of illusion I know of requires seeming: things seem one way but are actually another. When direct perception implies a false conclusion, that's an illusion. What else could "seems" actually mean? So now we're down to the meaning of the word "perception". I hope you also agree that there's no need to imbue some subjective subtext into this word, so where else can subjectivity hide?