3 ms·
I wish ARM made all their manufactures use UEFI. Microsoft did for their phones, but the bootloaders are locked. All the other ARM devices are SoCs with random
by djsumdog 10y ago
I wish ARM made all their manufactures use UEFI. Microsoft did for their phones, but the bootloaders are locked. All the other ARM devices are SoCs with random shit connected to random pins and non-upstreamable kernels. It's not a platform.
For a new design to work, it really need to be a sold platform, with a spec and kernels that don't need per-device images to boot and run. Device trees help, but they're just not enough.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoARM has the beginnings of that platform coming together, just in the server space. It's pretty much implementable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Server_Base_System_Architecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Server_Base_System_Architectur...
- mtgx 10y agoI'd rather they use Coreboot. UEFI is definitely coming "locked" to virtually all ARM-based devices, and my guess is Microsoft is at fault there, perhaps just by simply making it being locked the "default", and then the OEMs not bothering to change that.
- qb45 10y ago> SoCs with random shit connected to random pins and non-upstreamable kernels The non-upstreamable part is due to variety factors, including but not limited to dubious code quality, tendency to reinvent things in house and unwillingness to share code with competitors and develop common frameworks. UEFI won't help with these particular issues. As for random shit connected to random GPIOs (or mapped to random memory), you probably really want ACPI. Fwiw, ACPI is said to be coming to ARM and last time I heard Linux developers weren't exactly excited - ACPI means running opaque vendor-provided bytecode which pokes I/O registers behind the OS's back and, if x86 is anything to go by, contains countless bugs which can't be fixed without the vendor releasing firmware update and users applying it, so you end up with a collection of machine-specific workarounds anyway.
- amboar 10y agodevicetree is how this is all typically managed for Linux on ARM.