4 ms·
Will you invite anyone who so wishes to speak at your home? At your school? You have a right to speak, you don't have a right to my megaphone. Use the internet,
by andrepd 10y ago
Will you invite anyone who so wishes to speak at your home? At your school? You have a right to speak, you don't have a right to my megaphone. Use the internet, plenty of megaphones there.
Your freedom of speech does not trump my freedom to not support you. I can't glue your mouth shut, I can't hit you or threaten to do so, but I sure as hell can not give you my microphone.
- nyolfen 10y agoat my home? no, that's private. at a public university? yes. the constitutionally enshrined right to free speech does in fact trump you arbitrarily enumerated 'right' to not be uncomfortable.
- andrepd 10y agoI never invoked the right not to be "uncomfortable" so I would appreciate if you took down the straw-man. Are these public universities? Regardless, aren't the students in their right to organize counter-demonstrations? As long as they abide by the law and commit no crimes then surely the demonstration itself is not a crime no matter how it may irk some people?
- rendall 10y ago<< Regardless, aren't the students in their right to organize counter-demonstrations? As long as they abide by the law and commit no crimes then surely the demonstration itself is not a crime no matter how it may irk some people? >> I completely agree with you. Students should be able to organize counter-demonstrations as long as they abide by the law and commit no crimes. From the first paragraph of the article: "American college students are increasingly resorting to brute force, and sometimes criminal violence, to shut down ideas they don’t like." << Are these public universities? >> UCLA and Berkeley are public universities that are funded by taxes. Claremont McKenna College is not, although the speaker was invited.
- adekok 10y ago> I can't glue your mouth shut, I can't hit you or threaten to do so, but I sure as hell can not give you my microphone. When it's your personal microphone, that comment is reasonable. When it's a universities microphone, that comment is not reasonable. Universities have a set of rules as to who can and cannot rent their facilities. Those rules should be applied fairly and equitably to everyone. The upset here is that the rules are not being applied fairly or equitably. Worse, the people who claim to be for peace, for free speech, for openness and inclusion, are using violence to exclude the speech of people they don't like. Conflating "my" microphone with use of public facilities is a way to side-step the real topic.