4 ms·
Only if you simplistically ignore that social status and wealth are also heritable and make it much easier to make money regardless of intelligence.
by zepto 10y ago
Only if you simplistically ignore that social status and wealth are also heritable and make it much easier to make money regardless of intelligence.
- literallycancer 10y agoOne does not preclude the other.
- eehee 10y agoIf intelligence matters at all to making money, the wealth + intelligence combo probably beats wealth on its own. Unless, of course, intelligence is "bad" for the wealthy and "good" for the poor, but I doubt that's the case...
- zepto 10y agoSure - wealth + intelligence can be highly lucrative e.g. Bill Gates But intelligence without wealth can easily be beaten by average intelligence plus wealth and status. E.g. Trump
- zepto 10y agoJust to be clear - I'm comparing two billionaires who started off as millionaires, and suggesting that Gates is of above average intelligence whereas Trump is not.
- Houshalter 10y agoIs social status and wealth really heritable? There are studies of lottery winners that show their children and grandchildren aren't any better off.
- zepto 10y agoThis comment makes no sense. Wealthy families clearly pass down money and social status to their children.
- Houshalter 10y agoBut it doesn't last long. After 3 generations, maybe less, there's little statistical difference between those descended from wealth and those not (all else equal!) The super wealthy may leave billion dollar empires to their children, sure. But if we are talking about the upper middle class, a moderate inheritance from your parents isn't going to make or break your life's outcome.
- zepto 10y agoA moderate inheritance plus support during your education may well make or break your life's outcome vs someone born to a poor family. 'Inheritance' doesn't have to mean just what was passed down at death - it must also include all the additional resources available during development to have any meaning.
- Houshalter 10y agoBut it doesn't! That's the point. Otherwise the lottery winners kids would be better off since they could go to better schools and afford college. In general there's little evidence that education makes any difference at all.
- zepto 10y agoSeriously, your lottery winners example is meaningless. But if you are saying that education makes little difference to lifetime earnings, you're going to have to back that up with a reference because it's an extraordinary claim.
- douche 10y agoLottery winners are overwhelmingly white trash. Who would reasonably expect such people, with no experience of money, to invest their windfall reasonably?
- Houshalter 10y agoThe result isn't necessarily surprising, but it does show a point. Not all lottery winners blow the money immediately and foolishly. You would expect there to be at least some statistical effect. But it doesn't seem to matter. And it's probably the best randomized experiment we can do to compare the effects of wealth and not wealth, all other variables equal. Wealth doesn't' seem to matter as much as people think it does. It goes back in time too. Winners of 1832 Georgia land lottery were given free land of significant value by the government to settle and farm. After a few decades, they weren't any better off than the nonwinners.