3 ms·
We wouldn't need any of these techniques if advertisers weren't so abusive.(i know it's been said many times over) If you ever watch really old game shows like
by ravenstine 10y ago
We wouldn't need any of these techniques if advertisers weren't so abusive.(i know it's been said many times over) If you ever watch really old game shows like "What's My Line?", they sometimes show the same commercials from the 1950s; it's astounding to see commercials and promotions that are relatively short, not overtly distracting, and mostly focus on the merits of the product. If commercials were still like that, I'd probably still have a cable subscription, I might even be paying for Hulu, and I would even have adblock turned off. But the nature of the advertising industry is that if you give them an inch, they'll take a mile and then some. So while there is certainly a valid ethics debate around advertising and ad blocking, until the advertising industry changes their methodology that they've had in place long before ad blocking plugins were invented, I will have next to no sympathy for them no matter how unethical a piece of adblocking software might go. Though it's been said numerous times before, turning off adblock after having it on for a significant amount of time(e.g. to denormalize the prevalence of ads) is all the evidence one needs to see how completely messed up digital advertising still is.
Fortunately, many YouTubers and a lot of podcasters have already figured out that the way to go for advertising revenue is not through AdSense or stock preroll ads, but through having hosts themselves endorse a product for a portion of the show(that they have supposedly tried themselves) and making up the rest through Patreon. This harkens back to how many radio shows used to be and, honestly, it works because it's not very repetitive and the fact that the host is speaking for it says something. The corporate world either doesn't understand or like this, and are still gung ho to ram advertising down our throats. Better than adblocking, I rather just don't pay for their overvalued media to begin with. I don't pay for cable, I rarely go to the movies or buy them, I don't pay for Hulu, and I support internet shows that don't rely on AdSense. Life is actually pretty good when you pull most of your plugs.
- literallycancer 10y agoEthics are largely irrelevant here. The advertising industry will simply do what they have always done, which is the things shown by their models to bring the most revenue. Asking the advertising industry to be less manipulative is like asking casinos or supermarkets to stop employing behavioral psychologists to figure out the best ways to get people to spend money. >and the fact that the host is speaking for it says something In most cases (e.g. all except the ones where the host would mention the product even without any incentives), it just says that they value the money they get more than their viewers' attention.
- arghimonmobile2 10y ago> Asking the advertising industry to be less manipulative is like asking casinos or supermarkets to stop employing behavioral psychologists to figure out the best ways to get people to spend money. Interesting parallel. I'd be in favour of regulation of adtech. Probably the gambling industry could do with a little more, too. But then again, i'm a dirty socialist.
- soared 10y agoThose ads form the 1950s would be inneffective for most advertisers right now. Only "mcdonalds size" companies can afford generic advertising like that. With online ads anyone can spend $100 and it can still be very effective. Your problems with repetitive and irrelevant ads isn't because the marketing industry is bad, its because some advertisers don't know what they're doing and run bad campaigns. I agree that the industry will change - but only when the consumers force it to. Adblockers will eventually be widespread, and marketers will adapt to it with something else. The ads you mentioned you like aren't scalable - you can't spend $1000 in the next 20 minutes with those ads like you could with display ads right now.
- majewsky 10y ago> turning off adblock after having it on for a significant amount of time(e.g. to denormalize the prevalence of ads) is all the evidence one needs to see how completely messed up digital advertising still is. I have this experience every time I visit friends who don't have an adblocker. When we watch some videos or stuff, I'm like "Holy shit, this is what your internet looks like!?"
- H4CK3RM4N 10y agoYouTube in particular is really unbearable without adblock.
- davemel37 10y agoYou are focusing on the symptom not the root cause... Honestly, the blame here lies with the publishers, not the advertisers. The way they try to maximize revenue forces out the legit advertisers and only leaves room for bad actors...If advertisers truly controlled how they paid for media, we wouldnt have these bad actors... Case in point, when was the last time you felt an Ad on Google was disruptive or predatory or spammy? They forced quality score to determine the cost to advertise...Adwords is one of the most effective ad channels out there and one of the most expensive and its all because they aligned their offering with what was best for advertisers. As long as publishers sell ad space in a way that doesnt align with driving profitable ads for advertisers, youll get stuck with bad actors and deeply disruptive ads... As long as publishers sell eyeballs, we all lose...once they start selling context and results, and truly care about driving value for advertisers, we are doomed to this ad blocking world... The problem is not advertisers its publishers not aligning their offering with whats best for their users and advertisers long term