2 ms·
"Better" is circularly self-defining, because it really just means "More successful in a given niche." You don't really know what's going to be more successful
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
"Better" is circularly self-defining, because it really just means "More successful in a given niche."
You don't really know what's going to be more successful in a given niche until it becomes obvious.
As you say, there's no reason it has to mean "Worked harder", "Was technically superior", "Practiced more", or any of the other things it would mean in a less arbitrary world.
You can often increase your odds of success with all of the above, but a 1% change - whatever that means in practice, and however you're supposed to measure it - is always going to be swamped by effects outside your control.
- Retric 10y agoThat's just circular reasoning, your King because your father was the King who'd was King because his father was the King... But, the reality is someone is King because of their ancestors actions and accidents of birth etc. Further fitness is defined by inheritable traits. You can have a billion descendants with blue eyes you can't have a billion descendants who are all kings of England at the same time. PS: A useful rule of thumb is a justification sounds like a value judgement something else is going on.