4 ms·
Alt-right attacks Macron in last ditch effort to sway French Election
- empath75 10y agoI hope the French don't fall for this like we did.
- camus2 10y agoThe campaign is over so the leak will have no influence on the results. Macron has mathematically won already. But if he fails during his presidency, the far right will ultimately get the job. The truth is Macron is the candidate of the status quo, his party likely won't have the majority in the french house so he will have to compromise with both the "socialists" and the conservatives, he won't achieve much for 5 years.
- omginternets 10y agoTo reinforce your point about the status quo, it's been said in French media that this election is ultimately about globalization vs an alternative to globalization. Macron is the globalization candidate. Le Pen is something else.
- mhneu 10y agoLe Pen wants to damage France's relationship with the EU. That accords with Putin's goals. That's why the Russians hacked Macron's campaign and released emails today.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe hack of it's indeed a hack came at the worst possible time for propaganda as French media recievws a 48 hours gag order prior to the polls closing.
- mafribe 10y agoThat's why the Russians hacked Macro What is your evidence that this hack originated in Russia?
- mhneu 10y agoUS senators have said Russia has targeted the French election via disinformation and hacking. I linked some articles above. Or Google "Senator Warner Russian hacking France election" Warner is the ranking member of the Senate Intelligence committee. Are you disputing that?
- mafribe 10y agoExactly why are you suggesting that US senators are a credible source of information in this matter? US senators have also said that there are weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, and that Assad used chemical weapons against the Syrian population. In both cases, credible information has never been put forward to the public.
- camus2 10y agoMost of the french political landscape isn't anti-russian to begin with. Hollande stance on Russia was an exception. As for whether the Russians did it or not, there is absolutely no proof of it.
- mhneu 10y agoUS FBI said they know the DNC email hack was run by Russians. See DOJ press releases from October. US Senate Intel committee and FBI head has said US knows Russia is right now targeting the French election. These are facts.
- camus2 10y agoI don't believe a single thing any US agency says and I'm not american.
- omginternets 10y agoWhat's your point? The issue I'm raising is that a very significant portion of the French populace is "euro-skeptic". Recall that a few years ago, the French voted "no" to the EU constitution (by referendum), and were subsequently overruled by the government. Many French are still very pissed about this. Are you suggesting we not give them a democratic voice because Putin is also against the EU? That would be a very stupid move in a country whose national sport is going on strike. Are you suggesting the hack was coordinated by Russia? I'm not sure what this changes.
- DiNovi 10y agoThis is the media simplifying a complicated narrative into something more simple and... well, global. le pen isn't just "something else," she's a strain of nationalism that leads to people committing genocide in the name of country.. and ignoring history when it tells us this.
- illumin8 10y agoIsn't that the intention of these far-right wackos? The "official" campaign is over, so they can attempt to influence the results without worrying about the Macron campaign being able to deny the rumors? Twitter needs to decisively put a stop to these bot armies. It can't be that difficult to detect them through ML. The bot armies are not only responsible for propagating outright lies, they also frequently target people for online harassment. I've heard from many people that were almost unable to use Twitter due to information/message overload once they were targeted. Twitter seems to not only allow the harassment, but requires users to wade through the post spam. I would imagine at some point the usefulness of having a Twitter account approaches zero for many of these people that have been targeted.
- omginternets 10y ago>It can't be that difficult to detect them through ML. Show us the code. >far-right wackos It's also a mistake to put Le Pen in the same box as the likes of Trump. For one, she's a highly educated, and secondly, the far right in France has a rather long history of being the only party to say anything substantive on the topic of immigration and security. (It's worth noting that the immigration situation in France is very different from the US). I'm not a huge fan of Le Pen, but dismissing her as a "wacko" is exactly why she has maintained a growing electorate; each time media in France has tried to label her as a nutcase, they've essentially refused to address the very real concerns that motivate her electorate.
- illumin8 10y agoI'm not talking about Le Pen. I'm talking about the army of far-right wackos on Twitter that openly spout nazi memes and unleash bot armies on anyone who disagrees with them. Le Pen is probably a far right wacko as well, but I don't know enough about her to form an opinion.
- digi_owl 10y ago> the far right in France has a rather long history of being the only party to say anything substantive on the topic of immigration and security. That is the sad part about European politics. The (champagne) Left is so enamored by the notion of EU as a peace project, that they can't see that they are undermining their very voting base (the working class) in the process. This has left the doors wide open for the far Right to wrap their xenophobia in terminology that claims they worry about workers rights and livelihood, when they really want to see every last "foreigner" (anyone with enough skin color or other feature that makes him stand out from across the street) tossed over the border (at best).
- mariusmg 10y agoLet's hope the french are smarter than the americans. But anyway what's the deal with this in the mainstream french media ? Are they reporting this stuff ? Making a fuss over it ?
- diggan 10y agoNo, in France they have laws that the media can't report on elections two days before they happen. More information about it here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_France
- briandear 10y agoThey aren't allowed to: it was released too close to the media blackout deadline.
- raverbashing 10y agoSome are kinda reporting it, because of the Media "quiet" period as explained in the article
- Majestic121 10y agoWhat I saw about it (Macron's leak) is media saying it is probably authentic and an attack from Russia, but nothing about the actual content of the leaks. However, since it is just after a botched attempt to make believe that Macron has a bank account in the Bahamas, which was widely exposed as bs from 4chan, I don't think it will have much of an impact here.
- roguemanunite 10y agoOf course, more mainstream media BS. When someone hacks one of their precious "candidates" who loves "freedom", "liberty", and "rights" it's ALWAYS Russia or they frame Assange as a Russian spy. My god I hope the world governments burn. This trash system can't persist anymore.
- jamesrcole 10y agoSo who do you think is behind it and/or why do you think it couldn't be related to Russia? (I have no knowledge about this situation, I'm just asking you to back up your claims).
- travmatt 10y agoI think the intention is more to create confusion and paranoia rather than construct any coherent viewpoint.
- mhneu 10y agoConfusion yup. Also a goal is to crowd social media with nonsensical views to "make social media unusable.". This New Yorker article had a good discussion. http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-real-paranoia-inducing-purpose-of-russian-hacks http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-real-paranoia-in...
- pavlov 10y agoThe thing that I don't understand about this "mainstream media BS" critique is this: You say that the media is biased in its reporting, beholden to special interests, and doesn't abide by journalistic standards. Given that, the reasonable solution would be to create a media outlet that makes a conscious effort to be less biased, more open about its ties to any industry or other backer, and more stringent about its journalism. When I go to Breitbart (or any other alt-right news site), I don't see any of that. I see a new breed of media outlets that are even more blatantly biased, even more covert about who's paying them, with no semblance of journalistic integrity. It's like the alt-right looks at a problem and says: "They are doing X, and we oppose that. We must start outdoing them in X!" By the way, that approach is typical of organizations that strive simultaneously for both ideological purity and brutal pragmatism. The Bolsheviks did essentially the same. "We hate the Czar's secret police. [One year later...] We need a stronger secret police than anyone else." (Maybe the overlap in methods is no coincidence. Steve Bannon reportedly said he is a Leninist who wants to destroy the state.)
- briandear 10y agoI don't understand why Le Pen is being called "right" or "ultra right." Even a cursory review of her policy proposals -- specifically economic policy shows her closer to Melanchon than the free market "right" orientation of Fillon's proposals. She's national socialist more than anything -- ultra right socially, ultra left economically. I consider myself "on the right" -- but Le Pen is the worst of both worlds; the totalitarian racist zeal of Hitler with the industrial protectionism fervor of the worst socialist. By the way, when I say socialist, I don't mean the Democratic Socialism common in Europe -- I am referring to the statist socialism of the Soviet era.
- Majestic121 10y agoYou're absolutely right in your analysis : she is ultra right socially, hence why everyone call her ultra right, but she leans left economically. France's way of describing politicians is more focused on the social perspective than the economical one (otherwise, Macron would be on the right I think)
- bru 10y agoLike national socialism, you cannot label it "left", for it's mostly appearances and ways to get votes than real convictions and engagement.
- oelmekki 10y agoExactly. By the way, national socialism is exactly what lepen is doing : backing defense of the weak ones on nationalist views. I've had many discussions with people lately who were arguing that yes, it's nationalism, but it's also leading the social fight (I'm french). Each time, they were mind blown when I replied : "Yep, and that's called national-socialism". For some reason, they don't see the similarities by themselves. I guess we failed to explain clearly what nazism was, and now people think it's only about racism and don't detect it when it raises again.
- superiorrobot7 10y agoSure you can. The civic activists within the continental United States can absolutely be labeled as national socialists. Their tactics are closer to real fascism then what the labeled alt-right does. Tip for youngsters: if your opponent opposes immigration, don't call him a fascist or a nazi because those are two completely unrelated things.
- chvid 10y agoWell - it is a global fight against the globalists :-P I don't have any opinions on French politics other than it is an entertaining spectacle to watch. And I think it is already given that Macron wins as le Pen is still to harsh to swallow. Here is what's going on over at the "donald": https://www.reddit.com/r/The_Donald/comments/69ikwt/whoa_guys_were_truly_living_in_a_censored_world/ https://www.reddit.com/r/The_Donald/comments/69ikwt/whoa_guy... I don't know if it is true; but if it is then it is kind of amazing just how fast services we all take for granted can be censored (github and internet archives).
- DiNovi 10y agoProbably don't draw conclusions if you don't know its true.
- chvid 10y agoI think it is like having two radio channels; one saying one thing and the other the opposite. What can you conclude? Maybe that there is a lot of manipulation going on.
- Zapperino 10y agoIf it's from the_donald, it's most likely NOT true.
- koolba 10y agoOh really? How about when the CEO of Reddit (/u/spez) was personally editing people's comments? EDIT: Here's what I'm referring to: https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/5frg1n/tifu_by_editing_some_comments_and_creating_an/ https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/5frg1n/tifu_...
- DiNovi 10y agoit's all a conspiracy. Grab your bug bag and head for the hills
- oelmekki 10y agoAs a side note, I'm always surprised when I see the word "alt-right". When did that happen? I still use the word "fascists", although I understand it can be too strong a word for many, but those can use "far right".
- dogma1138 10y agoFascists can just as easily be used for many of those on the left too.
- digi_owl 10y agoFascism was/is in a sense socialism/communism for the rich and corporations...
- DiNovi 10y agodisaffected young men lacking strong in-person relationships doomed to a life of desperation due to lack of opportunity united online in praise of cartoon frogs and white supremacist fascism. History books are gonna be weird.
- mhneu 10y agoAlso those online communities are targeted by manipulation by foreign groups that want to polarize and weaken our society. http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2017/03/30/russia-s-info-war-on-the-u-s-started-in-2014.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2017/03/30/russia-s-in...
- DiNovi 10y agoYes, voiceless minority groups can be more easily targeted and taken advantage of. I read just yesterday about Somali immigrants being turned anti-vax in a matter of years due to outside influence, this is no different.
- tajen 10y agoI love your description because each word designates both problems and solutions. History books will go further and further: "WWI was triggered by an assassination in Sarajevo", "WWII was born in the black Thursday", and the next events "find their source in the solitude of some men with a computer, and we couldn't solve that. Solitude kills, after all.". Assuming the next event is related to alt-rights, of course.
- komerdoor 10y agoAlt-right? How did a term made up on 4chan get so popular and taken seriously (/pol where I saw this term used for the first time). It really has no meaning at all only to find a opposite alternative to (the also misused term) regressive-left. Before last year people did not even identify as such. People that now do identify as such do not even seem legit and behave like actors (the same feeling I have with people like Alex Jones). Now even people I would call moderate / left-leaning are now called alt-right (a term they do not use for themselves).
- DiNovi 10y agoIMO younger 4channers (18-23 set) that I have met in person strongly identify this way. It's odd cause 10 years ago 4chan trolled in the exact different direction. Would love to read a book about political reckonings that come from this tiny dark corner of the net.
- komerdoor 10y agoBut as far as I now the timeline is as follows (cannot find the 4chan threads anymore, so no proof this time): - Aug/Sep 2016 (or a short while before that): People made up thr term "alt-right" to be used as the opposite of "regressive-left". People there did not call themselves that. - Oct 2016: 4chan was mostly busy with all the Wikileaks stuff and I did not see the term used that much. - Oct (end)/Nov 2016: Some people (not even on 4chan started to call many things that are pro-Trump or "tried to be" objective (non Trump or Hillary) alt-right. The general message that started to come up at that time: "The alt-right are spreading fake news". - Dec 2016/Jan 2017: People suddenly started to identify themselves with alt-right. Update: Google trends timeline: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=today%2012-m&q=alt%20right https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=today%2012-m&q...
- DiNovi 10y agoalt right is from waaaaaay longer ago than September. It's all an out growth of "gamer gate" nonsense. Milo and Cernovich were both "gamer gaters." Bannon ran gaming message boards before Breitbart, where he met Milo. He figured out how to use messaging like his to target these people for less savory purposes.
- mafribe 10y agoTLDR: - Post goes out of its way not to deny authenticity of the leak. - Post can be traced to the Atlantic Council [1]. [1] The Atlantic Council (AC) is a core ingredient for US soft power [2] projection on other countries. Example members of AC leadership: Chuck Hagel, Susan Rice, Richard Holbrooke, General Eric K. Shinseki, Anne-Marie Slaughter, General Brent Scowcroft, Jon Huntsman. Cf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_Council https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_Council [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_power
- DiNovi 10y agoone thing Wikileaks does is give credibility to their leaks basically by putting their stamp on it that it's all authentic. This dump happened quickly and with no organization oversight - impossible for now to know which is real and which is fake. I was told 4chan put in some obviously fake bank documents, but that the emails seem real. It's something that willl play out for months now.
- mafribe 10y agoAgreed. Wikileaks has a sterling record regarding the authenticity of their own leaks. Given that the Atlantic Council is for all practical purposes an arm of the US government, and it's "Digital Forensic Research Lab" is extremely well-funded and well-connected, it is noteworthy that they go out of their way not to deny the authenticity on the leak.
- DiNovi 10y agoThis thread is a good reminder that dangerous thinking has infected a not small group of younger computer engineers. Quite frightening.
- simias 10y agoMany new accounts, there appears to be some brigading going on. I'm surprised actually, I doubt brigading hacker news is going to have a lot of weight in the outcome of the french election... Staying away from the political side of things, it's impressive how many people are willing to spread obvious disinfo if it serves their agenda. I'm sure many of these alt-righters realize that those documents are most likely fakes but it doesn't matter, whatever hurts the opposing party. Look at the Cayman document leak from yesterday, one of the laziest montages I've seen lately. Didn't stop it from being plastered everywhere on "alt-right" websites with big VERIFIED tags. It's just the strategy of drowning actual information in a sea of lies so that nobody bothers to look for it. The worst thing is that an actual leak about Macron's tax evasion could be released now and I probably wouldn't believe it. It's just all noise.
- oelmekki 10y ago> I'm surprised actually, I doubt brigading hacker news is going to have a lot of weight in the outcome of the french election... It's about all they have left :) There's a law in France saying that media can't discuss campaign anymore two days from election, the idea being that debate time is over and it's now time for each citizen to take a step back from the heat of the campaign and calmly decide what they think is the best for the country (this is obviously something that doesn't work as well now we have internet). So far right activists only have foreign discussion threads as a mean to spread.
- superiorrobot7 10y agoJust like the silent majority spoke and elected Trump, the same will happen to Le Pen. Also, I highly doubt it was the alt-right doing 'hacking', it's more plausible for it to be a determined patriot trying to stop corruption. My 2cents.
- DiNovi 10y agoTrump lost by 3 million votes. I do not think the term silent majority if accurate.
- candiodari 10y agoIt baffles me that the right actually has to convince leftists not to vote for Macron, never mind the means used. Macron is a Rotschild banker, personally responsible for anti-employee law changes [1]. He advanced as an international investment banker in a very suspicious, rocket trajectory straight to the top ... while making deals with government-owned banks [2][3]. Now I'm not saying he HAS to be dirty ... but ... euhm ... yeah actually I am. Unless someone can explain to me how to career like that fairly. [1] https://blogs.wsj.com/briefly/2015/03/09/5-things-about-the-macron-law-2/ https://blogs.wsj.com/briefly/2015/03/09/5-things-about-the-... [2] https://www.ft.com/content/9bd62502-12cf-11e7-b0c1-37e417ee6c76 https://www.ft.com/content/9bd62502-12cf-11e7-b0c1-37e417ee6... [3] (they de-emphasize this, so let me quote from the FT article: "On the Atos deal, Mr Macron “had a fairly junior role at the time — he would be asked to redo the financial models on Excel, the basics,” recalled an adviser. But a few days after the deal was announced, Mr Macron was made a partner. A few months later, he stunned colleagues and rivals by winning a role in Nestlé’s purchase of Pfizer’s infant food operations.")
- mhneu 10y agoThis is a tech news article about hacking. This is a core topic of Hacker News. It must be unflagged. @dang