7 ms·
My strange journey into transhumanism
- meamonb 10y agocool!
- pmoriarty 10y agoThis story reminds me of a little-known movie called The Rapture.[1] It lacks the technological spin, but is otherwise also about a lost woman adopting a strange, cultish faith. Some religious people have taken offense at its view of Christianity, and it's obviously a low budget movie, so you have to tolerate some consequences of that, along with a bit of soft-core sex, but otherwise it's really interesting and definitely a challenging view of religion. [1] - https://dvd.netflix.com/Movie/The-Rapture/60034962 https://dvd.netflix.com/Movie/The-Rapture/60034962
- scottlegrand2 10y agoIMO it's one of those rare movies with an ending that does not let the viewer down.
- RichardHeart 10y agoTranshumanists have a time-frame problem. They're very concerned with the opportunities and problems of people who are not going to be them. You must earn the right to be around to face those future challenges. As it stands, just like nearly all of the futurists of the past, they're dead, they don't get to see all the robots, flying cars and shiny clothes of 2017. Build the future you wish to see. Biotech, the life you save may be your own. If you like nanobots, try your hand at the white blood cell, it's pretty great at what it does. You'll get farther hacking it, than trying to build your own nanobot version. Same for trees. Pick up where nature left off. Nature's already done a pretty great job of it over the very long time it's had. Imagine the difficulty of building an artificial tree, compared to efficiently planting more.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThe problem with the genetic solution of the WBCs is that they are unstable. There are plenty of cancers and diseases affecting them (including autoimmune) and the complexity is immense. Immunology is a young science still, and it is only a small part of the war on aging. WBCs are grown and raised in a stochastic, vastly imperfect process. It might be indeed easier to build an equivalent from ground up, similar to how AI algorithms do not quite copy the neuron. Some are inspired by it, but not a copy. If everyone expected results immediately we would be nowhere now. Typically "normal science" works incrementally with occasional flashes of insight and paradigm changes.
- pmoriarty 10y ago"there has also persisted a tradition of Christians who believed that humanity could enact the resurrection through science and technology. The first efforts of this sort were taken up by alchemists." There has been some debate about what true goals of the alchemists were, and whether they were using religious language merely as a veil of indirection and as protection against the religious intolerance of their time. Some believe that the alchemists had religious motives, others that they were really after worldly wealth achieved through chemical means, others that they were after a psychological transformation. The entire narrative woven by this story is certainly fascinating, but I am not persuaded by the thesis that Christians deserve all the credit for the religious strains in the transhumanist and singulitarian movements. Similar aspirations are certainly reflected in these movements, but these aspirations are shared by many religions all over the world. Even if we limit the focus to just America, where the computer revolution could be argued to have been born, there are many religious influences outside of Christianity, such as the attraction to and adoption of Eastern religions by at least much of the American intelligencia in the 50's, 60's, and 70's around the dawn of this very computer revolution. Eastern religions have their own stories of transcendence and of humans essentially becoming gods. I am also reminded of Eric Voegelin[1], who thought many modern movements, from Communism to Fascism, were actually gnostic in nature, and sought to transcend humanity through knowledge. Some have characterized gnostics as a "Christian sect", but in fact they may have had influences from various religions and may have predated Christianity. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Voegelin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Voegelin
- mavdi 10y agoEveryone talks about extending life and eventually becoming immortal, yet no one asks what happens when we are immortal. What happens when one accumulates centuries of data and witnesses numerous traumatising events? I mean I'm 34 and I get ever more paranoid, suspicious and corrupt as I age. I can't image what 3400 years would do to my head.
- gallerdude 10y agoI'd rather solve immortality first, and figure out how to deal with it second.
- goatlover 10y agoImmortality is impossible. You'll die of something else if it isn't old age. Even your copies will die, and the means for making them will be destroyed at some point or succumb to entropy.
- aleeds 10y agoI think he meant "Why don't we solve dying of old age first". I think that is pretty obvious from context.
- red75prime 10y agoEntropy is non-decreasing in closed systems. Also you can make a habit of not keeping all of your copies in one solar system.
- pmoriarty 10y agoWould you really think of all of these "copies" as yourself?
- Koshkin 10y agoRight. Immortality is impossible without indestructibility. The mean time from birth to a fatal accident is probably around 200 years. But indestructibility is worse than mortality - imagine yourself stuck forever in a situation you can't get out of, like being accidentally buried inside a slab of concrete. What a boring life that would be!
- goatlover 10y agoThis talk of curing aging is curious given that we don't even have a cure for balding or the common cold yet. It's nice to dream, but it's in the realm of visiting other star systems at this point.
- marktangotango 10y agoVernor Vinge had a talk related to what if the singularity doesn't happen, he said people in that future would call the current era the Age of Failed Dreams.
- Mendenhall 10y agoI enjoy being mortal, can only suffer the fools for so long.
- peterwwillis 10y agoThis kind of philosophy revolves around a theoretically unlimited supply of resources, wealth, time, and of course a completely frictionless society. "Immortality" will eventually be possible in the form of biotech, given enough time with uninterrupted technological and medical progress. But before that happens we're going to be torn apart, either by our own humanity (nuclear war, politics/religion, pollution, overfishing, antibiotic resistance, etc) or nature (new ice age, giant meteor, etc). We can't even agree on why the seas are rising, much less decide to do anything about it. And these people think we're going to evolve? Not if we drown in ignorance first.
- exratione 10y agoIt is a strange journey that we'll all be going on, just through the incremental process of desiring and adopting improvements. https://www.exratione.com/2017/04/blind-upon-the-eve-of-apotheosis/ https://www.exratione.com/2017/04/blind-upon-the-eve-of-apot... But really, transhumanism is common sense. You see a problem and you fix it. That inevitably leads to the end of suffering, which requires medical control of aging, complete control of the biosphere, comprehensive neurotechnology, and so forth. The only open question is how long it all takes to run through the development pipeline. If longevity-assurance technologies existed, everyone would use them as a matter of course, just like people go to the doctor when they are sick, take vitamins, and go for flu shots. We're in a strange part of history at the moment, transitioning from a state of abject technological poverty, unable to affect our environment, to a state of technological wealth in which all of these items - aging, intelligence, the human condition - are becoming malleable. All of the mental and philosophical architecture put in place to enable people not to go mad in the face of death and limitations will come crumbling down, but not without a fight. Humans are nothing if not conservative at root, and all change is fought. Not an advantage in an age of vastly beneficial change, but it is what it is until the human mind changes.
- djokkataja 10y agoFull-length version: https://nplusonemag.com/issue-28/essays/ghost-in-the-cloud/ https://nplusonemag.com/issue-28/essays/ghost-in-the-cloud/