3 ms·
Whether Rand lived by her own ethics in my mind is less worrying than her so called philosophy itself. You don't need to go after her as a person to point out
by ThomPete 16y ago
Whether Rand lived by her own ethics in my mind is less worrying than her so called philosophy itself.
You don't need to go after her as a person to point out what is wrong with what she was fundamentally preaching.
- dualogy 16y agoWhat is wrong with what she was -- teaching?
- ThomPete 16y agoThere are so many things that are wrong with it. "The individual "must exist for his own sake" That "must" in there is basically undermining her own claims about rationality. It might very well be that the individual exist for his own sake. But "must"? That's a pretty unsupported moral claim and by no metrics rational. Her focus on the individual is in itself a very naive interpretation of reality. What individual is she talking about. No man is an island. The very existence of what we call individuals depends on so many factors from our ancestors to the existence of a live-able planet to the air we are breathing. If anything she wrote self-help books. To call it philosophy would be a crime to philosophy. Or what about A = A. Existence exist. But what is existence? That is the question you must answer before you venture out from the premise and start prescribing what is right and what is wrong.
- grandalf 16y agomust is used the same way should is frequently used. Moral philosophy allows that concept.
- ThomPete 16y agoWhich makes it no less problematic. It's still an unsupported moral claim.
- grandalf 16y agoWhat is a supported moral claim?
- ThomPete 16y agoOne that claims to be based on rationality.
- grandalf 16y agoRand's one premise is "Rationality is good" and she derives the rest from that.
- ThomPete 16y agoWhich is nothing but yet another unsupported claim. Rationality is also not good just as irrationality is both good and bad. Context determines not ideology. It's not rational to claim that the individual should exist for his own sake anymore than to claim that the individual should exist to pro-create or to secure the continuation of it's genes.
- grandalf 16y agoWell you might as well be arguing that the entire notion of "good" and "bad" is useless, which would make all of moral philosophy useless. That's a valid claim, but it's sort of tangential to a critique of Rand b/c most people who critique her simply prefer some other type of moral philosophy. Any notion of good and bad must start with something... Rand tries to back-fill rationality being good based on what is essentially an evolutionary argument. Not the strongest argument, but probably stronger than the premises used by most moral philosophers.
- ThomPete 16y agoBut even from an evolutionary point of view this doesn't follow. Even from an evolutionary point of view there isn't any "should" or "must". The theory of evolution does not consider itself with morals or ethics. There are no prescriptive moral in evolution. It's a model to explain, retrospectively, how things evolve not how it should or must evolve.