3 ms·
Huh? As a general matter, increased labour supply _does_ naturally lead to lower wage growth. That's simple supply and demand, which is about as "natural" of a
by wahern 10y ago
Huh? As a general matter, increased labour supply _does_ naturally lead to lower wage growth. That's simple supply and demand, which is about as "natural" of a phenomenon as you can get.
It doesn't necessarily lead to lower wage growth, of course, particularly when you take into account other factors that might change contemporaneously. For example there might be union or political pressure to redistribute more profits to workers.
But the point is that with an increase in the labor supply, ceteris paribus, we should expect lower wages, and thus lower wage growth averaged over the period before and after the change in labor supply. The persuasive burden should be on someone trying to prove otherwise. That burden might be easy or difficult to overcome, but we shouldn't mistake where the burden should lie. Otherwise we're rejecting basic, sound economic theory.
- fulafel 10y agoBut of course it's not "ceteris paribus" since those new labourers are are wage earners, their consumption results in more economic activity, and so the wheel of prouction and consumption spins faster. Take a thought experiment in the opposite direction, if 50% of the labour force decided to drop out, and so there would be about a 50% drop in GDP - do you think there would be big real wage increases for those who remained employed?
- wahern 10y agoIf 50% of the labor force dropped out, I would absolutely expect wage increases. I'm ignoring the claim of a 50% drop in GDP because that muddies the waters, and is conclusory; precisely the thing I think we avoid if we stick to my original point. Yes, we know that "ceteris paribus" is a lie--other elements of the equation will always be different. Moreover, there are complex feedback mechanisms at play. But _how_ they're different is what matters, not simply that they're different. Precisely because those second-order effects are so complex is precisely why people relying on them for their argument should hold the burden of persuasion. I don't think that should be controversial. Yes, it's a PITA. I'm tired as much as anyone else of conservative economists and conservative politicians applying economic laws too simplistically, arriving at conclusions completely at odds with _reality_. When our conclusions differ from reality, that's a strong hint we should look for the flaw or missing element in our model. But none of that justifies shifting the burden. Once you shift that burden you've effectively discarded the laws of supply & demand, and have put earnest, learned critics on the same pedestal as charlatans and radicals. Once you prime people to accept the more complex, non-intuitive answer over the simpler answer, you've poisoned public discourse. That's how you end up in a situation like Venezuela. Venezuela isn't broken because it's corrupt; all those working poor knew the government was corrupt while voting for them. But people there believed the destructive and poisonous criticisms of liberal economics, and so are simply no longer able to accept even the most basic precepts of supply & demand.