5 ms·
Considering the amount of money that large political parties pay for high-six-figure salary media consultants, stylists, image consultants and PR fluffers....
by walrus01 10y ago
Considering the amount of money that large political parties pay for high-six-figure salary media consultants, stylists, image consultants and PR fluffers....
You would think they would want to hire a few professional, highly qualified NetSec sysadmins and give them authority to enforce network, server and endpoint security policies over an organization as a whole. But nope.
DNC is a fine example of failing to prioritize network security.
edit: I mean it's not exactly rocket science in terms of recruiting. Find a person who would be qualified by their years of experience and proven track record to be the chief security officer at an organization the size of cloudflare, limelight or netflix (or similar) and offer them a job at an equally high salary. Pay relocation and COLA expenses.
- egourlao 10y agoEn Marche! was only founded within the last year. Although they attracted a considerable amount of donations, not sure we're talking about the same scale of money.
- Signez 10y agoAlso, accounting in French political campaigns are very restricted to ensure fairness between candidates (no more than EUR 4'600 per candidate per physical person, no business donations; the total expenses are capped to ~22m€). Accounts are checked after each elections by the National Commission on Campaign Accounts and Political Financing; it is an active check, as some of the previous campaigns refunds were blocked because of some wrong doing. More details available on Wikipedia (translated from FR): https://translate.google.fr/translate?sl=fr&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=fr&ie=UTF-8&u=https%3A%2F%2Ffr.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FFinancement_des_campagnes_pr%C3%A9sidentielles_en_France&edit-text=&act=url https://translate.google.fr/translate?sl=fr&tl=en&js=y&prev=...
- PierreRochard 10y agoShouldn't this be a government expense, and not a campaign expense? Do candidates pay for their own physical security?
- Signez 10y agoActually, ANSSI (French government agency for the security of IT) gave some workshops to campaign teams. Source (in French): http://www.zdnet.fr/actualites/lection-presidentielle-l-anssi-en-renfort-pour-eviter-toute-ingerence-39849222.htm http://www.zdnet.fr/actualites/lection-presidentielle-l-anss...
- PierreRochard 10y agoWow, so this really was a catastrophic failure on multiple levels. Lotta of self-reflection for some in Paris this weekend!
- noelrock 10y agoGet real. Political campaigns, outside of the States, are very much bootstrapped. And IT folks very much not minded to volunteer their time. Citation: I'm a member of a European Parliament on his third term in politics. Of my 200+ volunteers, not one is in infosec. Within my party, maybe 60 staff total are paid for a campaign.
- topranks 10y agoWow you are a TD? On hacker news? Wonders never cease.
- alva 10y ago> Political campaigns, outside of the States, are very much bootstrapped Get real. edit: Considering the response perhaps I should qualify. The major parties in most developed countries have permanent election teams with multi-million pound budgets. I cannot see why my response is in any way controversial.
- ceejayoz 10y agoThe US is mostly unique in having 18-24 months to fundraise, A/B test, staff up, etc. edit: Regarding this... > The major parties in all developed countries have permanent election teams with many multi-million pound budgets. That's very likely. However, the bursty nature of elections means they're probably also onboarding thousands of volunteers and temporary staff in a very short period of time.
- walrus01 10y agoa Canadian political campaign (Federal) lasts at most 45 days, with probably an estimated 45-60 days of additional lead up time to prepare for it when it's obvious a vote is going to be called... The parties still seem to find plenty of money to spend on 4/5-star hotels, chartered airplanes, staff, etc.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fixxer 10y agoThey do. Obama campaign had a contract firm that implemented and enforced infosec. They even tossed USB keys in the parking lot to catch campaign workers that we're dumb enough to try them. The problem is beyond rote security at this point. We're in the realm of talented, well financed threat actors with databases of 0days.
- balls187 10y ago> The problem is beyond rote security at this point. We're in the realm of talented, well financed threat actors with databases of 0days. State actors
- fixxer 10y agoI think that is likely the case, but I don't know if that is an exclusive thing anymore. A lot of what I read about reminds me of 1970s sponsorship of various terror entities and revolutionaries.
- walrus01 10y agoFrom a nation state actor standpoint it is probably a lot cheaper to pay gobs of money to a half-dozen antisocial young black hat types (that have been messing around with linux since age 12 in their bedroom in belarus), than to fund the PLO.
- fixxer 10y agoYep, and if you look at the carders in Russia, they have some very close ties with government. Perfect infrastructure for this shit.
- kafkaesq 10y agoYou would think they would ... Um, yeah, they've thought of that (and have been told that 10,000 times) already. Just that it turns out these organizations -- and the threat models they face -- are a bit more complicated than you would seem to think. And the task of finding qualified and, crucially, trustworthy people who can also interface with the sprawling, chaotic, and (inherently) politicized juggernauts that underlie these campaigns, even more so.
- zzzcpan 10y agoSome ex-cloudflare/limelight/netflix chef security officers certainly won't be able to do anything against state actors.
- kafkaesq 10y agoYou can name-drop all you want. These people have heard it all. But the short answer is, if they can't interface with the rough-and-tumble reality (and day-to-day insanity) of a scrappy political campaign... then no, their technical chops (by themselves) just won't do all that much. won't be able to do anything That's some pretty crude hyperbole (as I'm sure you're already aware).
- walrus01 10y agoI don't think there is a great deal of venn diagram overlap between political apparatchik/ass-kisser and the sort of person who you want to hire as CSO of netflix or a similarly sized organization. Hiring a competent CSO who could deal with the politics and actually has the technical skills to deal with nationstate sponsored zero days... that's a hard problem.
- terri_cat 10y agoImagine the competence of government employees but without the financing.
- wavefunction 10y agoI find the competence of government employees quite acceptable and even at times commendable given my quality of life. But then I also understand how the rest of the world has to get by which makes me appreciate what I'm fortunate enough to have. The weird thing I've noticed is that some people in my country will express your sentiment, but then turn around and tell you they live in the best country in the world and would be offended were anyone to say otherwise. I guess they don't see the connection between the government workers and that quality of life.
- cloakandswagger 10y agoYou think quality of life is synonymous with quality and competence of government. This is the problem.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoWhere in the. modern world is this untrue?
- threeseed 10y agoAs someone who has worked in government I take offence to this. There are plenty of very qualified people in government who do want to help make the country a better place. They are often just dealing with out of date processes that are mandated by law and which limit their ability to be innovative.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoYeah. I take issue with those people that have given up demanding that their government do better. They are defeatists.
- davidf18 10y agoBoth DNC and also the Clinton Campaign (Campaign Chairman Podesta). Podesta was hacked by pfishing which most users < 30 knows to avoid. Tells me Podesta had no geek friends.
- walrus01 10y agoworse, podesta actually asked their sysadmin "is this legit" and was told, paraphased "yup, click on it and enter your credentials". https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2016/10/28/13456368/how-john-podesta-email-got-hacked https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2016/10/28/13456368/... "Seemingly skeptical (and rightfully so), Podesta forwarded the email to his chief of staff, who then passed along the email to the campaign’s IT team. This is where things go so painfully wrong: The campaign’s IT team incorrectly identified the email phishing for Podesta’s password as legitimate, instructing him to change his password."
- hackuser 10y agoAmazing; I hadn't seen that story. Vox doesn't prove that this particular phishing attack was the way the attackers got access to Podesta's email, but what an unbelievable failure by their IT team. Who would fall for this? The phishing email claims to be from from Google support, and tells the user: > CHANGE PASSWORD: <https://bit.ly/[deleted]> https://bit.ly/[deleted]> That should be enough red flags. Also, the bitly address expands to one in the domain, myaccount.google.com-securitysettingpage.tk
- Natsu 10y ago> Vox doesn't prove that this particular phishing attack was the way the attackers got access to Podesta's email If you visit the stats page for that bitly link by adding a + to the end, you'll find that it was visited exactly twice, both visits at the right time for the hack, and you'll find that the Wikileaks data cuts off soon after the hack, probably when they set up 2FA as suggested. While that doesn't technically prove that they're related, it's better evidence than we have for any other theories. Sources: Bitly stats page: https://bitly.com/1PibSU0+ https://bitly.com/1PibSU0+ Phishing email: https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/34899 https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/34899
- openasocket 10y agoI wish. We're still trying to get tech companies to prioritize security.
- ItendToDisagree 10y agoI wish I could upvote this to the top of every thread regarding security.
- TimPC 10y agoI think the biggest issue is the short campaign time. You have to pay a pretty big premium to get someone to quit a job with good stock bonuses for 45 days of work. It’s also very challenging to implement a full security Implementation solo in one week (or whatever aggressive timeline is needed to prevent hacks from day one). Hiring a team is cost prohibitive in most countries.
- walrus01 10y agoThat is absolutely true. Not going to recruit a person like that for just 45 days. Organizations like the DNC need to have such a person on staff full time, 365 days a year, whether an election campaign is active or not.
- monkey88 10y agoPoliticians are still campaigning with outdated mindsets, so securing their computing environment is not a priority. But looking good on camera, oh yeah.