3 ms·
> Voting for a demagogue needs to carry a heavy social cost, or nothing will change. To me this means anyone who found either top US candidate as a viable opti
by dmix 10y ago
> Voting for a demagogue needs to carry a heavy social cost, or nothing will change.
To me this means anyone who found either top US candidate as a viable option, so am I supposed to dismiss the majority of Americans merely because they voted? Personally this was an off-topic and non-relevant aside that served no purpose but to start flamewars. Politics is a mind-killer.
Not to mention hardly everyone who visits HN is even from the US and those outside of it (in western countries who have experienced stable/functional political systems) are very likely looking at the whole thing as a sidehow rather than who one voted for as some deep analogous reference to the topic at hand.
- CalChris 10y ago> Politics is a mind-killer. If you think this is so then don't talk politics. But if you're asking us to be Good Germans that's not going to happen.
- dmix 10y agoShoehorn your politics into conversations all you like. That's why we have downvote buttons on HN.
- CamperBob2 10y agoSo, it's OK for the Trump crowd to "shoehorn" their politics into every inappropriate venue they can find -- for example: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/at-fda-tvs-now-turned-to-fox-news-and-cant-be-switched/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/at-fda-tvs-now-turned-to-fox-new... -- but the remaining 74% of us are expected to remain on topic at all costs. Do I basically have your position correct here?
- dmix 10y ago> Do I basically have your position correct here? No, obviously not, how would the exact same thing but of a different US political position make it okay? Did you not see my above comment? I admit I may be expecting too much from expecting basic comprehension from the type of audience who likes to engage in this 24hr news network partisan stuff... all I'm trying to get across to you guys is that this isn't the place for it. You may find /r/politics and /r/worldnews much more welcoming, or the comment sections on the websites of major US news networks (CNN, Fox news, MSNBC, etc). But as I said I will continue to downvote/flag it here.
- CamperBob2 10y agoTo me this means anyone who found either top US candidate as a viable option There was certainly nothing "non-viable" about Clinton. If you didn't like her, fine. Neither did I. But if you live in a swing state, you are partially responsible for the consequences of your decision. It wouldn't be a problem if those consequences were limited in scope to you, your family, or the people of your state. But they aren't. ...so am I supposed to dismiss the majority of Americans merely because they voted? The majority of Americans did not vote for Trump. Approximately 26% of them did. Source: https://mises.org/blog/26-percent-eligible-voters-voted-trump https://mises.org/blog/26-percent-eligible-voters-voted-trum... Out of respect for HN's commenting guidelines I'll leave it at that.