4 ms·
It's interesting that I've felt the least welcome in places that are advertised as tolerant safe spaces. This is especially true when it comes to performance ar
by djsumdog 10y ago
It's interesting that I've felt the least welcome in places that are advertised as tolerant safe spaces. This is especially true when it comes to performance art such as spoken word poetry. I've been accused of "using words that weren't yours to use" and after one open-mic, the MC reminded everyone they reserved the right to "play people off the stage."
Part of being in a society with free speech is listening to ideas you don't agree with. Being offended is part of growing as a society. It was once offensive to publish pro-homosexual magazines in Universities. It was once offensive to say God isn't real.
I highly recommend Brendan O'Neill speech on the Right to Offend. It's amazing, and you'll notice at the end, there are many who boo and disagree with him.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtWrljX9HRA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtWrljX9HRA
- scribu 10y agoI agree with you, but I have a comment about the video you linked to. O'Neill gave several examples of views that in the past were regarded as "maximally offensive", but they were all progressive - they advocated for a new idea, something that was never accepted before in that society. But are there any examples of regressive views that were initially considered offensive but later accepted?
- gizzlon 10y agoHm.. probably, right? :) Maybe the flatness of the earth? Think "the world is flat" was considered the new science in parts of the world.
- colordrops 10y agoAren't progressive and regressive relative to the norms and morals of a particular time and community?
- scribu 10y agoYes, and my question doesn't assume universality. I'm asking about views that were considered regressive or progressive at that particular time, by the particular people that were advocating for tolerating or for suppressing those views.
- dtzur 10y agoThank you for sharing this. I was having trouble articulating my view on the subject and that guy nailed it. A must watch.
- rabbyte 10y agospeaking for myself it's not ever the offense I take issue with it's the ubiquity of popular offense. that every space must be a space wherein offensive speech is permitted including spaces created to cater to other genuine concerns such as recovery from debilitating trauma. churches have been a safe space for certain kinds of thought for centuries, some churches even creating a safe space within their safe space where a person can confess to any sin without suffering the adverse social affects. it's on this point that I think people lose their minds. the vulnerable see a world completely set against them and have no ability to create an island for themselves so they over react and become militant with time as popular social movements continually fail to understand them. I see wrong on both ends for different reasons but in a hyper connected world where everything is happening all the time, the marginalized by definition must lose out. the freedom to offend is not the only attribute worth protecting, despite how very serious our history teaches us otherwise. the world isn't just becoming smaller, it's becoming flat, and that is another dimension worth pushing against. there are no easy positions to take here. there are no obvious answers. defending free speech is obvious and good and I'm in favor of erring on the side of caution but the longer people take a principled stand on offense and dismiss the motivations of the people pushing against it, the further this situation will deteriorate.