3 ms·
I don't understand this, myself. Why isn't this calculation implemented as a mechanical state machine? It's impossible to implement a 5,700,000-year cycle wit
by CamperBob2 10y ago
I don't understand this, myself. Why isn't this calculation implemented as a mechanical state machine? It's impossible to implement a 5,700,000-year cycle with an individual program wheel, but three or four smaller, simpler ones should be able to do the job.
Hard to see why this is considered a difficult problem at this point, 2000+ years after the Antikythera Mechanism.
- ZoeZoeBee 10y agoThey mentioned it in the article. It is impossiblly difficult to know all of the variables which cause a time shift over a period of time as long as 5 million years. You could build it but you'd most likely be wrong eventually, failing to compensate for the unknowns >The date of Easter encodes a strange kind of orderly disorder, and yet, even that is an expression of an abstraction that only approximates reality. Over a period of 5,700,000 years, as Bryan Hayes points out in his 1999 article on Y2k compliance and the Strasbourg clock, things like tidal drift will cause enough variation in the orbital and rotational periods of the Earth that any algorithm will require ad hoc correction anyway
- CamperBob2 10y agoBut that's not the issue at hand. The watch needs to last a few hundred years or a couple thousand at most, not 5 million. At those timescales the problem is quite deterministic and perfectly solvable, especially when the mechanism is already keeping track of the date and lunar phase. A mechanism that only works for 28 years shouldn't have been contemplated by a company that literally advertises their products as heirlooms.