I just want to say that this is probably the best online discussion I have ever seen. Scott and Giulio respond to each other in clear, well thought out, detaile

I just want to say that this is probably the best online discussion I have ever seen. Scott and Giulio respond to each other in clear, well thought out, detailed posts. Christof Koch and David Chalmers chime in in the comments section of Scotts blog, and all of the commenters there really try to contribute something substantive to the discussion. I'm super impressed, as in, the internet is actually better than I thought! ;) I would really recommend to anyone interested in that discussion to take the 3-4 h it takes to read through it all.