4 ms·
> From the bubonic plague to smallpox, we have evolved to resist them We have antibiotics for plague, and vaccination / eradication for small pox. That doesn't
by DanBC 10y ago
> From the bubonic plague to smallpox, we have evolved to resist them
We have antibiotics for plague, and vaccination / eradication for small pox. That doesn't feel like we evolved any resistance. A couple of thousand cases of plague are reported to WHO each year.
- raulk 10y agoIn a way, we did evolve to acquire the brainpower —and invent the tooling and the methods— with which we managed to discover the vaccines and cures to effectively eradicate the diseases.
- pesfandiar 10y agoWe have evolved to resist if we assume our intelligence is an extension to our body, and intelligently managing diseases is an extension to our immune system.
- fhood 10y agoYou are being pedantic on purpose.
- castis 10y agoWhich do you have an issue with, the idea, or the person expressing it? While we're at it, I can't recall the last time I met an accidental pedant.
- fhood 10y agoThe idea is neither novel, nor does it add to the discussion. It simply purposefully distorts the original commenter's intended meaning for "resistance".
- pesfandiar 10y agoI'm only proposing an interesting and different way to look at it, as opposed to correcting DanBC.
- alpha_squared 10y agoThen, with that same line of thinking, we were capable of resisting for quite a while but just lacked the know-how to do it?
- adrianN 10y agoThere has been some genetic adaption to the plague: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/03/050325234239.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/03/050325234239.h...
- badosu 10y ago> That doesn't feel like we evolved any resistance. If you take into account the infection of native Americans compared to Europeans since the 15th to 19th century [0] you'd infer that some ethnic stratum really evolved a lot of resistance wrt. to smallpox. Conversely, because of smallpox eradication I would guess that some part of the population probably regressed on that. The spread of disease from European contact was not always accidental. Europeans arriving in the Americas had long been exposed to the diseases, attaining a measure of immunity, and thus were not as severely affected by them. Therefore, disease could be an effective biological weapon. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Native_American_disease_and_epidemics#Disease_as_a_weapon_against_Native_Americans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Native_American_disease_and_ep...