4 ms·
Tech lifestyle options and programming languages are topics where plenty of objective truths can be established. Why else would anyone want to waste air and key
by btilly 16y ago
Tech lifestyle options and programming languages are topics where plenty of objective truths can be established. Why else would anyone want to waste air and keystrokes?
They are also topics where there are plenty of subjective truths. Worse yet, many are subjective truths where the answer, although entirely subjective, is incredibly important to people.
The canonical example in programming is the question of the best indentation style. Research has found little difference between virtually any brace placement, and any indent in the range of 2-4 characters. Yet consistency is incredibly important, and programmers will experience some level of disorientation when forced to work with an unfamiliar indentation style. This effect is strong enough that people don't like to switch, even from an objectively worse style, for instance an 8 character indent (known to hurt reading comprehension), The infamous result are endless arguments that can't be settled.
(Diversion, I carefully said "little difference". In fact differences have been found. One is that programmers whose eyesight is getting worse - which happens with age - a 4 space indent is better than a 2 space indent. (A study that found this is referenced in _Perl Best Practices_.) The other is that there is some data suggesting that certain code inspection techniques work better if you've aligned your braces. See http://groups.google.com/group/golang-nuts/msg/ce9a377eef52aec9 http://groups.google.com/group/golang-nuts/msg/ce9a377eef52a... for the information I have.)
Moving on from that, there are plenty of decisions which likely have some objective content, but much, much more of the subjective content where people face large switching costs. Examples of this include your choice of editor/IDE, programming language, OS, and key libraries. There may be objective differences, but the key fact in the vast majority of arguments you see about this is that the people arguing would personally be worse off were they forced to switch.
- _delirium 16y agoIt might also be worth noting that the attempts to establish objective pros/cons of programming languages themselves usually start with a subjective decision about what ought to be maximized. For example: how do you weight things like prototyping speed, bug minimization, support for team programming, programmer satisfaction, etc.? Most studies pick one. That's useful objective information going into the decision, of course, but I still think the programming-languages decision is mostly a subjective one, depending on how people assign weights to lots of noncomparable factors. That doesn't mean it's totally arbitrary, because you can come up with cogent arguments for and against various things which help in understanding the pros and cons, but I don't think those are "objective" arguments that can establish "truth".
- asdflkj 16y agoIf you're used to some system of indentation, for some definition of "used to", then it is either objectively true that you'd most likely be better off switching, or it is objectively true that you most likely wouldn't be. If this truth can't be established, then it doesn't matter how important the answer is--it can't be established. Labeling it "subjective" doesn't get rid of the problem (unless, as I said before, the problem lies in acquiring a comfortable feeling of certainty).
- btilly 16y agoThe truth is that you, personally, are usually better off staying the same. But everyone is much worse off if you're allowed to go your way and someone else their different way. Therefore it is everyone's interest for someone to take that hit, and the argument is really about who is going to be forced to adapt.
- asdflkj 16y agoSo where do the supposed limitations of objectivity come in? What value can be attained by switching off objectivity in this scenario?
- btilly 16y agoPerson A will give many reasons why person B should switch to A's style, and A shouldn't switch to B's style. There seldom, if ever, any objectivity in those arguments.