5 ms·
And geothermal energy is a too-often-overlooked technology. It's not intermittent like wind and solar. It's more like nuclear but without the emotional baggage.
by Robotbeat 10y ago
And geothermal energy is a too-often-overlooked technology. It's not intermittent like wind and solar. It's more like nuclear but without the emotional baggage. As we try deep decarbonization, we're going to need more things like geothermal (or nuclear) or we'll end up spending like 2 or 3x as much money over-building solar to provide enough power even on cloudy winter days, building many more wind turbines, etc.
The hard part isn't getting to 60-80% clean energy, it's getting that last 20%. Geothermal helps a LOT with that. (As does nuclear, which is why we should be protecting existing nuclear assets until fossil fuels are eliminated... The existing ~20% of our electricity in the US produced by nuclear will make deep decarbonization multiple times cheaper than relying solely on wind and solar alone, plus accelerate deep decarbonization by a decade.)
An interesting idea is to build geothermal and solar at the same site.
Consider areas where these two maps overlap in high potential for both:
Geothermal: http://www.smu.edu/~/media/Site/Dedman/Academics/Programs/Geothermal%20Lab/Graphics/SMUHeatFlowMap2011_CopyrightVA0001377160_jpg http://www.smu.edu/~/media/Site/Dedman/Academics/Programs/Ge...
and
Solar:
http://www.nrel.gov/gis/images/map_pv_us_june_dec2008.jpg http://www.nrel.gov/gis/images/map_pv_us_june_dec2008.jpg
Places like New Mexico and southern Colorado are good fits for this.
A problem with geothermal is if you draw heat too fast from the ground, the output will decline over the years. If you stop drawing heat, the ground will warm back up and then when you start again, output will be higher than it was when you stopped. So there is some sense in conserving geothermal power when demand for it is low.
So the idea is, you draw from solar when the Sun is shining and draw from geothermal when it's not. By being co-located, you can use the same grid infrastructure and get higher utilization out of your powerlines. You've essentially converted some of your solar energy into a baseload power source. Or you can think about it as enhancing the output and lifetime of your geothermal power source.
(And it's possible that if you have a LOT of extra solar power, you could run a resistive load underground, using the ground as a makeshift thermal battery.)
- tclancy 10y agoIf you're interested in tracking the efficiency of your geothermal install, there's an app for that (which I helped build): http://groundenergysupport.com/ http://groundenergysupport.com/
- Robotbeat 10y agoI might be interested if you didn't call it "geothermal." :D (Just kidding, that's a cool app.)
- Declanomous 10y agoFrom what I understand, the big hurdle for 100% renewable is not replacing the power stations that provide base load power, but rather replacing peak load power stations. Hydro is often used for that, but in the Midwest the peaker stations are almost entirely run with natural gas. Replacing those often involves some way of storing energy that you've generated in a renewable fashion. The issue is that storing large amounts of energy is not easy, especially when you live in an area that could be described as flatter than flat.
- Robotbeat 10y agoStoring energy for a few hours isn't that hard. I have no doubt we can store for 4 or even 8 hours of average load to replace all the peaker plants. It's the multiple-day cloudy spells during the winter when you really need that last 20% of power capability. It's not feasible to store energy like that for 200-1000+ hours (there are ways, but they're very, very difficult and generally inefficient... deep sea hydrogen storage, for instance). Since we have decent short-term storage tech, it's not the peaker plants I worry about but the constant baseload. Peakers will be replaced by utility-scale storage.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Diederich 10y agoMr. Musk said that the world would need about 100 gigafactories in order to produce enough batteries to level out solar production off hours. One factory is producing batteries now, and Tesla is announcing three or four new gigafactory locations by the end of the year. It's a start.
- ogrisel 10y agoThe first factory is not complete yet. According to Wikipedia: Tesla held a grand opening on July 29, 2016 of the operational facility, having only three of the final 21 "blocks" of the gigafactory built out, or approximately 14 percent of the final factory size expected by 2020. By September 2016 Tesla had spent $608 million on Gigafactory.
- Jweb_Guru 10y agoI think it's possible that geothermal and hydro can get us 20% of our total power (though that relies on very optimistic estimates being correct), but I think that's misunderstanding what we actually need baseload for, which is when wind and solar aren't working to provide either enough, or any, power (for whatever reason). You need to be able to replace all of their power for relatively short periods of time (though to sustain our current lifestyle, probably longer), not 20% of their power all of the time. Being able to ramp up a bunch of normally idle natural gas plants at a moment's notice lets us do that right now, but part of that is that existing natural gas plants don't necessarily all fail at once... whereas wind and solar plans would have pretty correlated failures.
- Robotbeat 10y agoWhat that 20% does is lets you stretch your storage capacity much more, especially when combined with some demand-response and the remainder of the reduced capacity wind and solar (photovoltaics will basically ALWAYS produce /some/ power during the day, even if it's cloudy). It helps tremendously. I do think we'll use batteries for immediate power instead of natural gas. And the natural gas plants we DO have (hopefully not many of them!) could be more efficient because we won't have to ramp them up and down quickly, so we can use the much higher efficiency combined cycle plants. (But this idea of replacing nuclear with renewables and peakers seems really dumb to me... it's clearly a step backwards in emissions when we should be targeting fossil fuel plants for shutdowns. The fact that supposedly "green" people are pushing this is really, really weird.)
- afterburner 10y ago> It's more like nuclear but without the emotional baggage. ... and crazy costs (construction, maintenance, decomissioning, waste disposal, much of it obfuscated under general energy budgets, de facto government subsidy, or optimistic amortization).
- Robotbeat 10y agoThe maintenance is fairly low. Decommissioning and waste disposal are already included as a small fuel surcharge. The costs for construction are very high, for one main reason: time. Due to inexperienced contractors, legal battles, etc, it often takes a decade or more to finish a nuclear plant which DRAMATICALLY increases costs and reduces the option value. But all that could be dramatically reduced, in principle, without sacrificing safety or even needing dramatically new designs. Nuclear innovation really needs to focus on the construction process. Get that down to 2 years or less, and the cost problem will be solved.
- afterburner 10y agoDecommissioning goes over budget too. Fukushima was partly a result of people not wanting to swallow the decomissioning cost, preferring to extend the nuclear reactor's life beyond what they probably should have. Waste disposal is not a solved problem. Are you aware of the Westinghouse bankruptcy due to nuclear projects, possibly taking Toshiba under with them? https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/29/business/westinghouse-toshiba-nuclear-bankruptcy.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/29/business/westinghouse-tos...
- ogrisel 10y agoand the risk that a catastrophic event would bankrupt a large nuclear power plants operator or even an entire state.
- simonebrunozzi 10y ago> A problem with geothermal is if you draw heat too fast from the ground, the output will decline over the years. If you stop drawing heat, the ground will warm back up and then when you start again, output will be higher than it was when you stopped. So there is some sense in conserving geothermal power when demand for it is low. This sounds like a battery to me. Good problem to have :)
- nickik 10y agoPeople seem to ignore one of the most promissing things for stable load. Solar can actually do it, solar thermal. It is clean, relativly easy to build, shared tech with gas on the turbine and can have it produce power 24/7. You just heat up a pot of something and let it cool during the night, still producing energy. Cheap, green, stable.
- hwillis 10y agoGreen, but definitely not cheap or stable. Thermal solar is not very efficient and the plants are extremely complicated. They use molten salts that can freeze solid inside the pipes, and are also extremely potent oxidizers capable of starting huge fires. Ivanpah is expensive and consistently underperforms and has to make up the difference with natural gas. It freezes solid each night and has to be reheated. The nature of thermal solar also means you can't really take advantage of scale, so the problems aren't likely to get any better even if they get built even bigger. There is essentially zero chance that solar thermal will ever be better than batteries. Ivanpah has 392 MW of capacity @ $2.2 billion, and produces 1.75 GWh per day. Utility scale solar panels are below $1.42/watt[1]- $557 million installed, with land, tax, and inverters. The average price of lithium batteries is below $150/kWh, which would be 788 million for 3 days of storage. Altogether that's 61% the cost of Ivanpah using the average prices from last year. It's also roughly on par with current electricity prices (12.2 cents vs 10.3 cents, but NB residential is 12.6 cents) Solar city claims panels costing 55 cents per watt and Tesla expects to get below $100/kWh for cells by 2020. If those prices held the cost for a solar plant with 3 days of storage would be 740 million, and the cost of electricity would be 6.8 cents/kWh. [1]: https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2016/09/29/nrel-u-s-utility-scale-solar-costs-fell-below-1-50-per-watt-in-q1-2016-with-charts/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2016/09/29/nrel-u-s-utility-scal...