4 ms·
How does that apply to a place like HN? What's the common case for anonymity here? Sure, I'll accept the occasional exception, but what's the benefit for anony
by jasonlotito 16y ago
How does that apply to a place like HN? What's the common case for anonymity here? Sure, I'll accept the occasional exception, but what's the benefit for anonymity?
- ugh 16y agoI don’t want everyone I know to be able to search for my name and find everything I ever wrote. Just as none of my friends knows every discussion I ever had with everyone.
- jasonlotito 16y agoThat's understandable, but doesn't benefit HN. It's purely a selfish reason, and I don't think it brings any public benefit with it. Besides, these are public forums, not private emails. How does it benefit the public? Finally, while it's a little point, HN has a pretty restrictive robots.txt file.
- MichaelSalib 16y agoIt benefits HN because it makes people willing to comment here. People like ugh who do want to their discussion comments tied to their real name on google for all eternity will not participate at HN if they can't use a pseudonym. An HN without ugh and the many pseudonymous commenters like him would be a much poorer HN. Discussion forums are subject to network effects where the value of the forum increases with the square of the number of commenters.
- jasonlotito 16y ago> Discussion forums are subject to network effects where the value of the forum increases with the square of the number of commenters. More commenters doesn't increase value. I think my issue is more that "ugh" isn't anyone. He has no background, and therefore, what he says is purely within the context of the discussion. Anything he says is questionable, because their is no accountability. Anyways, good discussion. I'm still struggling with the baby/bathwater issue this has arisen, but the wife and child are waiting to be taken out to breakfast, so I must go. =)
- ugh 16y agoOh, I have no problem giving you information about who I am. Yeah, I could just lie, but I guess that’s something you have to live with on the web. I’m a 22 year old social science student from Germany. I have hardly any CS background and no startup background at all. Any more details you want to know?
- loup-vaillant 16y ago> He has no background, and therefore, what he says is purely within the context of the discussion. Which is precisely the intended effect: it makes you judge the writer by the writing. > Anything he says is questionable, because their is no accountability. So you need to know who someone is to asses the reliability of what is said? That means you know little about the subject matter, and don't intend to learn more. It's okay most of the time. We can't know everything. But if you are looking at a thread here, that's probably because you're interested in the subject. In that case, not being able to judge a comment by itself would be unacceptable.
- billswift 16y agoYes. Unless it is pure opinion, or you are willing to spend a lot of time tracking down references for what he wrote, then who the person is has a STRONG bearing on their reliability.
- jasonlotito 16y ago> Which is precisely the intended effect: it makes you judge the writer by the writing. It wouldn't be fair to judge non-native english speakers this way. However, if you are referring to what is being said, then it's not as easy as just reading what they wrote. Indeed, the majority of people out there can't discern reality from fantasy. I did a study on this 15 years ago, where it showed conclusively that presented with factual looking information, even professionals in the various fields were unable to discern fact from fiction on specific topics. ;) Simply put, without anything to verify this comment, you have to judge it purely on what is said. Accountability, credibility, attribute are all critical.
- ugh 16y agoIt’s not purely selfish. Some probably wouldn’t contribute here if they could not be anonymous. Quite a few people on HN who are valuable contributors are anonymous.
- jasonlotito 16y ago> It’s not purely selfish. Some probably wouldn’t contribute here if they could not be anonymous. Quite a few people on HN who are valuable contributors are anonymous. Maybe this is a case of the baby/bath water problem. Would comments improve if accountability is improved? Would overall comments/discussion improve?
- ugh 16y agoI can only tell you that I’m pretty sure that my writing would change. I really don’t know whether quality in general would improve. It might but you might also lose many valuable contributors in the process. I certainly have no problems with communities in which you have to use your real name. It’s a valid path to take, I just would much prefer to keep on commenting here anonymously. But a change of that policy wouldn’t be the end of the world. I would just abandon my old account, register a new one and probably comment a lot less and differently.
- dunstad 16y ago_why
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- bufordtwain 16y agoSome people don't want potential future employers googling them by name before making an offer and finding something that turns them off. For example, perhaps you are an atheist (and revealed that in your comments somewhere) and the future employer is fervently religious. This is potentially a bad situation for the commenter. If comments weren't anonymous then these folks probably wouldn't make their comments at all. So I think you get a more honest discussion if it's anonymous, at least for some topics.
- jarek 16y agoAt the risk of sounding idealistic and spoiled with freedom and lack of commitments (which is, well, accurate right now), I'm not sure I'd want to work for an employer who wouldn't hire me because of something I've posted on the internet. It's the 21st century. Yeah, a lot of my life is on the internet and relatively easy to find. It's almost like having a free, instant private investigator for all of your potential employees. But do you really want to work for a place that not only sets a PI on you, they put weight in what he reports when they know it might not be totally accurate? For people who do need a job a bit more than I do, that is a concern — and I wouldn't advocate against pseudonymity because life is not always nice and simple.
- qw 16y ago> For people who do need a job a bit more than I do, that is a concern — and I wouldn't advocate against pseudonymity because life is not always nice and simple. That's why I am very careful about my identity online. I have no problems with finding jobs right now, but who knows where I'll be in 10 years?
- jarek 16y agoFortunately, being 23, time spans that far into the future might as well be in the next century so it's not a large concern for me :) (That, and I think I have a pretty foolproof plan B for when everything breaks that I would be reasonably OK with executing.)
- HeyLaughingBoy 16y agoI have a pretty uncommon name. Google reveals a total of about six people online with the same first & last names. For the most part, I don't care if people know who I am, but I occasionally make statements that I may not want my employer knowing about and I really don't want to have to watch everything I say. ---- As an aside: I'm not big on meta posts, but would you guys stop downvoting jasonlotito, please!!! Whether or not you agree with him, he is asking intelligent questions and is furthering the discussion. Your downvotes are actually inhibiting the process.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Qz 16y agoI'm in the same boat. Near as I can tell I am the only person with my first and last names. If you put just my first name into facebook's search box I am one of only two people that show up. Googling first-and-last returns only me.
- crystalis 16y agoAnything that decreases the probability of an occurrence such as http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943356 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943356 should probably be rejected.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ColinWright 16y agoOn another forum I used to post under my real name. From a discussion where a disagreement arose, albeit be civil on line, the discussion turned nasty, and I was increasingly harassed until I was genuinely concerned for my personal safety. You might say that if everyone was identifiable then it wouldn't happen, but how would be verify the identities? Someone could take exception, then track you down off-line. Call it irrational, but that's my personal experience. On in exceptional circumstances would I post under my real name again. Being on HN is good, but not good enough. Finally, the source code is available, I'd be interested to see someone enhance it to require real, verifiable names and see how popular it becomes.