4 ms·
They already do a lot more than the US do, Edward Snowden even said GCHQ do metadata and data collection wholesale. Not to mention the random SSL downgrades th
by dijit 10y ago
They already do a lot more than the US do, Edward Snowden even said GCHQ do metadata and data collection wholesale.
Not to mention the random SSL downgrades that happen when you're going via UK transit links. (Which I have experienced myself!)
The UK should be considered dangerous. And the current government is only going to make it more dangerous.
There is also little to no hope of the current government being ousted during the next election.
I'm quite upset that my home country has to be so anti-freedom and anti-privacy.
- turblety 10y agoIt's also quite sad that a big majority of the country is ambivalent of this. Despite having access to this news, many still feel this is okay. Why are people not outside parliament protesting? Why are there no big campaign/organisations in the UK trying to get people together to protest this? Are we already too late and the government is now censoring and breaking apart potential protest groups. People have got to get away from this idea that they should trust the government. Maybe this government is mildly democratic however it doesn't mean in the future it always will be. Protections need to be implemented now to protect from future governments not just the current.
- DanBC 10y ago> It's also quite sad that a big majority of the country is ambivalent of this. Despite having access to this news, many still feel this is okay. Why are people not outside parliament protesting? People sometimes volunteer to have their DNA taken and matched against the police DNA database when there's been high profile crime of sexual violence. People just don't care. They think (mostly correctly) that the Government knows everything about them anyway, what does it matter if they get metadata too. RIPA made things a bit more complicated - it meant that in theory everything now had controls and checks and balances on it. But we know that those were boken, and that the oversight of GCHQ / MI5 / Special Branch / etc was rubber stamping stuff that should not have been happening. But because of RIPA people vaguely think "they get it all with a warrant". It's important to recognise that approximately zero people care about this, and it's not going to feature in any election manifesto (except for niche parties such as the greens). Many people don't care that the NHS is being destroyed, and that's a much bigger problem.
- arethuza 10y agoWhat I wonder about is what people are going to do when they find out that maybe it wasn't the EU or immigration that has been causing the problems with the NHS but straightforward bad management by a succession of governments and not so subtle attacks from right wing that can't stand that we have a much loved and successful service that is explicitly socialist. The crisis in the NHS is intentional.
- aembleton 10y agoProbably start electing governments that take action. Future governments will no longer be able to blame the EU.
- mike-cardwell 10y agoI'm 36 and I don't remember a time when NHS wasn't about to collapse, or be destroyed by the Tories. Meanwhile, the NHS has been around for about 70 years, and nearly two thirds of that time was under the management of the Tories. I'm pretty sure, 50 years from now, when I'm 86, people will still be telling me that the NHS is about to be destroyed by the evil sinister Tories.
- arethuza 10y agoNote that I didn't single the Tories out for criticism - New Labour was just as bad.
- DanBC 10y agoThere's a clear difference between the problems in the NHS today and the problems in the NHS 5 / 10 years ago. No one who works in health and social care is asking for unconstrained NuLabour style funding sprees. But now that they've made the NHS ruthlessly efficient, and we have NICE, it'd be a good idea to pay for what we know works, rather than weird ideas like 8 - 8 GPs, or 7 day services. (Especially since the information used to push 7 day services is a lie, and we've seen people die as a result.)
- scrollaway 10y ago> Why are people not outside parliament protesting? Because it requires effort. And if the british people go through with that effort, the government will wait, and do it later. It's a cat & mouse game except there's one cat and 200 mice. And the mice can fly. And throw the cat in jail. People aren't going to fight to delay issues. Hell, I'm very much an activist and I sure as hell don't have the will to fight for delays, how would you expect the general population to? If there's a solution, a real solution, people can fight for it.
- astrobe_ 10y ago> It's also quite sad that a big majority of the country is ambivalent of this. Despite having access to this news, many still feel this is okay. Why are people not outside parliament protesting? Because they don't realize what it means. Maybe doxxing a John Doe (with his approval, of course), and then saying "now, Internet companies and intelligence agencies can do ten times more because they have even better tools and/or have access to even better data" - that may open some eyes. Maybe someone should open a "doxx-me.org" website, that would let you doxx yourself. Of course this means it lets you doxx anyone, so it would be ethically questionable (well maybe that's more a suggestion for 4chan than for HN). On the other hand, I think it's important to know what others can know about you using these tools - in other words which parts of your privacy are exposed.
- r3bl 10y ago> Not to mention the random SSL downgrades that happen when you're going via UK transit links. (Which I have experienced myself!) Could you expand on this or provide us with some links? My Google-fu is failing me on this one.
- dijit 10y agoGoogle-fu is failing me to, but I've seen this personally so I know it's real. I'll try to emulate the test case and submit to HN. I think it's somewhat likely that google has removed the links to this in the interest of national security.
- narrowrail 10y ago>I think it's somewhat likely that google has removed the links to this in the interest of national security. This sounds highly unlikely considering Google is one of the main contributors to solutions to mitigate this problem. Also, I think you are referring to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transport_Layer_Security#Downgrade_attacks:_FREAK_attack_and_Logjam_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transport_Layer_Security#Downg...
- Symbiote 10y agoThe first-past-the-post voting system is to blame. Politicians need only argue in the newspapers (mostly owned by Murdoch), once they've won the election they can mostly do as they please. In a functioning democracy, the politicians would need to debate and compromise in Parliament, not in Fleet Street. The difficulty is in changing the voting system. Both the Tories and Labour were too shortsighted and greedy when the referendum was held. If it had passed, then soon after the Tories wouldn't have felt so much need to appease UKIP voters, and Labour could perhaps now split into two.
- libeclipse 10y ago> Not to mention the random SSL downgrades that happen when you're going via UK transit links. (Which I have experienced myself!) I live in the UK and have never experienced this. Could you provide a source? I don't think that is something that's happening.
- dijit 10y agoIt happens, but usually on traffic passing through the UK from europe on it's way to USA, and I don't know the intricacies of how it works but it doesn't downgrade high profile ports/IPs (like google, facebook). in my case it was a IRC server which was built identically to another 2 nodes in other parts of the world- When I looked into why I found no good reason so I dug in to it and was presented with a GCHQ/NSA project called "Tempora". I ran a bunch of tests using the popular `openvpn` software suite and a bunch of VPS providers who were cheap enough (tilaa, vultr, linode and AWS) and the common trend was exactly what I described. If I pinned the ciphers then the data would not be tampered, if I allowed a weaker cipher then my "response" would say the server was only capable of TLS1.0 despite me connecting to the same server minutes earlier on a different port with TLS1.2. I will do a write-up on this and submit to HN as I assume this is still in place and all references to what I describe seem to have been removed from google. I'm beginning to feel like one of those tin-foil hat people since I spent considerable time looking at documents surrounding this before and it's just vanished. :(
- paralelogram 10y agoIn 2003-2004 I had a non-SSL IRC server in a German datacenter and found that something between my server and large British ISPs was rewriting all "ISON <nickname>" strings in TCP streams to "PRIVMSG <nickname> :!kapa". I moved the IRC server to another IP address and never had this problem again. I think that GCHQ was monitoring the network traffic and had a bug in their IRC protocol implementation.
- libeclipse 10y agoI'm skeptical, but unsurprised. Did you eliminate all other factors? Bugs on the client/server side? When you do this write-up, or if you need any help with it, pop me an email (awn#cryptolosophy.io).