4 ms·
He's showing that things are screwed up. We're spending too much on education for what we are getting in return. He's claiming that the system is wholly ineffic
by pyre 16y ago
He's showing that things are screwed up. We're spending too much on education for what we are getting in return. He's claiming that the system is wholly inefficient. He's just extending that to the health care system in that one-liner.
More generally: "For the amount of money that we are putting into <blank>, we should be getting more value out of it."
- houseabsolute 16y agoThat is not what the article _says_, though.
- pyre 16y agoIt's just phrased differently. Stating that investing the money in the stock market or in developing nations would have a greater return on investment is just another way of stating that we're doing something wrong that is wasting significant amounts of money.
- houseabsolute 16y agoFirst of all, that's not the assertion I was talking about in the comment you originally replied to. I was talking about his stated position on doctors and hospitals. But anyway, the rest of the article is crock too, and if you're curious why you can read my other top-level comment.
- swombat 16y agoThe article is basically claiming that if a doctor earns $100k a year, and costs, say, $1m in funds to be able to complete his or her extended studies (that take many years), then creating that doctor is not a worthwhile investment for parents or for society. That's wrong on so many levels that I won't even bother to argue with it.
- bufordtwain 16y agoMaybe there are some highly specialized occupations (e.g. theoretical scientist) where the high cost of education is justified. But the point is that most people don't go into those fields.
- anamax 16y ago> The article is basically claiming that if a {knowledge} earns ${number} year, and costs, say, ${bigger_number} in funds to be able to complete his or her extended studies (that take many years), then creating that notfunh is not a worthwhile investment for parents or for society. For a given value of {knowledge}, there are values of {number} and {bigger number} for which that statement is true. There are other values for which it is false. Suppose, for example, it cost $1b to train a straw basketweaver and society was only willing to pay $10k for said basketweaver's output. That's not a worthwhile investment. And substituting doctor for basketweaver doesn't much change things. Absent force, salary/compensation doesn't capture all of the value that society places on an occupation, but it isn't hugely wrong either.
- anamax 16y ago> For a given value of {knowledge}, there are values of {number} and {bigger number} for which that statement is true. There are other values for which it is false. Actually, there are values of {number} and {bigger number} for which that statement is true regardless of the value of {knowledge}. I suspect that there are values for which it is always false as well.
- pyre 16y agoHow many doctors are unemployed and living with their parents? Don't take the statement about hospitals and doctors and try to combine it with the statements about the education system. The former was just a jab at the healthcare system, the later is a jab at spending gobs of money just to end up with people that aren't doing much of anything with their education. Doctors that go out and do something with their education (i.e. work as a doctor) aren't included in that.