Um, you seem to be operating on a confusion of ideas. Materialism does not imply that humans are logically consistent. The universe in which we exist is (prob

Um, you seem to be operating on a confusion of ideas. Materialism does not imply that humans are logically consistent. The universe in which we exist is (probably?) a logically consistent system, but that's true for both materialism and non-materialism. The difference between the two is which set of rules the universe runs on, not whether those rule sets are internally consistent. When I say "systems that are perfectly logically consistent" and "humans... aren't", I'm saying that the ideas humans have in their heads are not logically consistent. It's possible to write down "2+2=5" on a piece of paper, even if 2 plus 2 doesn't actually equal 5, and it's likewise possible for humans to believe "2+2=5" even if 2 plus 2 doesn't equal 5.