5 ms·
Film makers don't want to use VR. It is very limiting. Films in 3d were never very good, mostly because of the limitations it placed on camera movements. VR
by sandworm101 10y ago
Film makers don't want to use VR. It is very limiting. Films in 3d were never very good, mostly because of the limitations it placed on camera movements. VR will be the same. When you cannot control what the audience is looking at you must resort to tricks, repetitions and slow pacing to ensure that they see what they need to before you move on. The beauty of film, over theatre or other "3d" experiences, is that the director can grab the audience by the eyeballs, force them to see what he wants/needs them to see. That's why films can be so much faster and more direct than live entertainment.
Take your favourite movie, or even one you just hated. Think of how it would be to "sit in" the action, tilting your head to look at anything and everything. You will miss all the details. You will miss the facial cues, the many non-verbal interactions between characters, because you were instead looking at the shiny thing in the corner. VR is for interactive experiences and theme park rides, not the carefully controlled storytelling of film.
Think of GOTG, of sitting in the spare seat of a spaceship during a battle. Every time a character says something you will hear it, but miss seeing them actually say it because you didnt know to look at them in time. Think of all the wasted effort to animate Rocket's face if the audiance is never looking at him while he speaks.
- drdeadringer 10y agoCinequest film festival in San Jose, CA this past year added VR to their offering of entertainment delivery. Granted it was a mix of VR films, VR scene immersions, and panel-like how-to discussions, but doing so was an interesting choice.
- CharlesW 10y ago> Film makers don't want to use VR. Creators often like to play with multiple mediums. I'd give filmmakers the benefit of the doubt, and assume they understand that VR is a much different medium.
- jonchang 10y agoWell, VR films are a different medium, and I would expect that VR filmmakers would have to work harder to get the effects they want. This would necessarily result in relinquishing some amount of control over what people can see -- which is fine! How have video games like Half Life 2, which never takes control of the player's camera, find ways to get players to look in the right direction? There's a lot of techniques like using lighting and other cues, without beating the players' heads with loss-of-control cutscenes.
- jamesrcole 10y ago> Film makers don't want to use VR It may well be that those who do want to use VR for this won't be coming from the ranks of traditional film-making. I imagine a lot of them will be young, and will be jumping into this without a significant background in other media.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoPhotographers don't want to use cinema. It is very limiting. When you cannot give the audience time to take an image in, you must resort to tricks, repetitions and pacing to ensure that they see what they need to in the frame. The beauty of photography, over cinema or other "motion" experiences, is that the photographer can grab the audience by the eyeballs, force them to see what he wants/needs them to see. That's why photographs can be so much faster and more direct than films.
- sandworm101 10y agoFilm and photography are too similar for such comparison. Film is inclusive of photography. Everything that can be done in photography can also be done in film, especially with today's devices that display both as easily. VR is different. There are things in film that cannot be done in VR, as there are thing in VR that cannot be done in film. But in terms of storytelling, VR is to film as the "Choose your own adventure" is to novels. By allowing the viewer too much freedom to ignore one path for another, the artist's message becomes lost. To defend his message the artist will resort to trickery, extra efforts that detract from the work. A Disneyworld ride can be fun, but we don't expect anything near the depth we would from a film.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI'm not sure that you're imagining the correct kind of VR content here. Imagine a film as set in VR where you are simply seeing the film from the first person perspective of one of the main characters, but it is otherwise still a film, i.e. you have no control over movement, pacing, plot, etc. It's just a film that you see from a different perspective, rather than something more akin to a videogame with watcher agency which you seem to be implying. I think this format has a decent chance of taking off. Hell, it's already taking off in VR porn.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoYou can't get closer to cinema. You can't take your time.
- PhasmaFelis 10y ago
- beeandapenguin 10y agoThe Tribeca Film Festival hosted a VR immersive this year. There was a showcase of several creative VR films and experiences. I'd say filmmakers are diving head first into VR. The descriptions of the films sound fascinating. https://tribecafilm.com/immersive https://tribecafilm.com/immersive
- dylan604 10y ago"Film makers don't want to use VR. It is very limiting." To an extent, I'd agree as I myself miss the ability to use different lenses, set the framing, etc as storytelling devices. However, it is a matter of knowing the limitations of the medium, and not forcing "traditional" film making techniques into the new medium. Only frustration will result. However, this format is new and evolving. Part of the idea is to give the viewer control over everything. Forcing a traditional linear story line is going against the grain of VR. More and more projects are coming out with a "choose your own adventure" concept. Now that the tech is getting better, the tools content producers have to use will allow for more interactive content to be made. If the tech survives long enough to get there.
- agar 10y agoI heard an interesting interview with a filmmaker who was adamantly opposed to the terms "VR filmmaking" and "VR cinematography" - and not for the reasons you would expect. To him, cinematography is an art and a science. Nearly 100 years of experience has gone into understanding lighting, scene composition, set design, focus, directorial decisions, blocking, framing, etc. VR throws all of that knowledge out the window. As you say, camera motion is constrained. Cues change. Scene design is completely different. There's no quick cut, no soft focus, no depth of field. It is as different a set of skills as photography and painting. But, unlike your pessimistic view of the future, he was (verbally) jumping out of his seat in excitement at the new challenges, and new opportunities this completely new medium could provide for storytellers. Sure, VR storytelling is at the "Trip to the Moon" phase of refinement but it sure won't stay there. Don't compare current film to future VR. Future VR stories may (will?) be something completely unique unto themselves.
- sandworm101 10y agoMy view of the future is only pessimistic if one assumes that VR is the future. Im pessimistic of the medium, not the future of film or storytelling. I didnt support the "4d" craze either. That too came to nothing and film survived.
- thenomad 10y agoI'm a filmmaker who moved into developing VR experiences, and I couldn't agree more. Film and VR are vastly different media.
- phantom_package 10y agoBy definition, the people that make interesting cinematic experiences in VR won't be "film makers". I don't know if we've created a job title for them yet. It's a completely different medium, with completely different advantages, drawbacks, and considerations. Applying film techniques in a virtual environment is not the right approach, as your examples demonstrate. The really compelling experiences in VR will embrace the constraints you mentioned, not try to emulate a medium in which they didn't exist. I went to New York a few months ago and saw a play called Sleep No More. It takes place across 5 floors of a warehouse, converted into an incredibly immersive series of sets. It's loosely-based on Hamlet, with multiple storylines playing out simultaneously in different parts of the hotel/hospital/graveyard/theatre. The audience wears fawkes-esque masks and is not allowed to speak, nor are they acknowledged by the actors in any way. You can wander anywhere you like, follow any actors you find interesting, rummage through drawers, read books you find lying around, etc. You really do feel like a ghost, and being able to move around the actors (or even leave the room, if you feel like it), is incredibly fun and interesting. It certainly didn't feel like a limitation. So maybe VR has more to learn from theatre (and specifically interactive theatre) than film? Food for thought.
- mch82 10y agoYes! Theater and sports
- thenomad 10y agoSleep No More is one of my usual touchstones when talking about narrative in VR. (Speaking as a VR dev here.) In general, narrative in VR has to be approached VERY differently to film. It's not just that the viewpoint's moving or that it's 360 degrees, it's also that the viewpoint has its own agency within the environment. Of all the comparisons I've come up with, actually, pen-and-paper roleplaying games seem to be the most useful ones when discussing how to fit narrative into a VR context. There's a commonality of simulated world and tension between experience and narrative there that doesn't really exist anywhere else.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Findeton 10y agoI do not agree with this.
- robert_tweed 10y agoIn addition to the other replies, IMO, VR film-making isn't even a thing yet. 360 videos are not VR. Right now, VR exists as a medium in the form of games and other sims using real-time rendering. Film-making will require light-field cameras, which don't yet exist in any practical sense. However, progress is being made: https://techcrunch.com/2016/04/11/lytro-cinema-is-giving-filmmakers-400-gigabytes-per-second-of-creative-freedom/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/04/11/lytro-cinema-is-giving-fil... As for how it would work as a medium, I would compare storytelling in games with cut-scenes to something like Skyrim. One is about showing the story to a passive viewer, the other is about immersion in the story. They aren't directly comparable. Ulimately though, I think even light-field photograhy will be relatively short lived. The future will be simulated reality: essentially current game engines with much better rendering (possibly real-time path-tracing like Octane/Brigade). The reason being, you can film an actor, but unless you transfer that performance into a simulation, it cannot react to a nearby human. Another thing that will most likely emerge to address similar problems from a different angle is "virtual theatre" this already exists to a limited extent in the form of multiplayer games. Whether these will most resemble tradition artforms, or most resemble current-gen games remains to be seen. However, even games are starting to come of age as an artform and we're seeing more games that are closer to traditional stories (without relying on cutscenes), or interactive art (e.g., Journey). Also two of the most popular games of all-time, The Sims and Minecraft[1], are technically not even games. These distinctions are going to become more and more obvious in VR, and new categories will emerge as the audience moves away from traditional gamers and other early adopters, into the mainstream. [1] Only applies to Minecraft in sandbox mode.