2 ms·
> It's the distinction between programming consciousness and physically reproducing it. Except that there is none: consciousness is "programmed" into our brain
by Koshkin 10y ago
> It's the distinction between programming consciousness and physically reproducing it.
Except that there is none: consciousness is "programmed" into our brains (by hard-wiring + social experiences); artificial intelligence is "physically reproduced" as a mesh of transistors and higher-level structures built from them - logic cells, LUTs, FPGAs, PSMs, CPUs, HPC clusters, etc.).
(Partially relying on software is not an issue: even a brain completely simulated in software could, in principle, exhibit consciousness just as well as a "wetware" one can.)
- rocqua 10y agoWhile I completely agree, your arguments only work for materialist views. To dualists, it is anything but obvious that consciousness arises from physical processes in the brain.
- castle-bravo 10y agoSure, but the dualist hypothesis doesn't explain any phenomena that can't be explained by the materialist hypothesis. There is no reason in principle why consciousness couldn't emerge from purely physical processes.
- unabst 10y agoIntelligence is not consciousness, nor is it conscious. When I make a decision, I tap into my data and my knowledge, but the "I" is not inside that data nor did I emerge from it. The topic of artificial consciousness would be Artificial Consciousness or Artificial Agency. The ability to get things right is not to be confused with knowing what is right. Or put another way, you could be a complete idiot and still exhibit your will and perfect agency.