3 ms·
Well, yeah--after the fact, it doesn't really matter if you experienced terrible pain that you didn't remember. But by that argument it's fine to torture babies
by philwelch 16y ago
Well, yeah--after the fact, it doesn't really matter if you experienced terrible pain that you didn't remember. But by that argument it's fine to torture babies, since they won't remember it.
The question is whether, before the fact, you would go into minor surgery without anesthetic at all knowing perfectly well that you would forget all of the pain afterwards. Maybe you would if it was the best option, but I would wince in anticipation.
- _delirium 16y agoYeah, I think I would wince at it, but I don't think I'd be that opposed. Somehow to me the idea of pain that I know up front I'll never remember isn't all that frightening a prospect, though I suppose I'd still avoid it given the option. It feels almost as if it's really just my body that'll experience pain, not "me", in the sense that I won't remember anything about it, it'll have no lingering traumatic effects, won't be an experience that'll do anything to shape my personality, etc. I'd definitely be much less apprehensive about it than if I knew I would remember it.
- philwelch 16y agoHence the eternal philosophical problem with thought experiments (or "intuition pumps" as some people call them)--different people have different intuitions so maybe your thought experiment won't even make sense to them :)