3 ms·
You will need to expand on that "work together" bit before I will be convinced that you can explain consciousness. Also, can you identify maximal rewards in a w
by mannykannot 10y ago
You will need to expand on that "work together" bit before I will be convinced that you can explain consciousness. Also, can you identify maximal rewards in a way that does not become self-referential when the actions are things like listening to music or climbing a mountain?
- visarga 10y agoAll the human rewards are related to survival (food, shelter, communion with others, sex, learning, and so on). It's interesting, but we bootstrap meaning "by death" - those that do not appreciate sex, don't get to send their genes in the next generation, for example. It means something to like sex because otherwise it means non-existence. Appreciation for nature, music and other artistic pursuits are related to an internal reward that favors exploration and creativity which are essential skills in problem solving, which is essential for survival ultimately. In machine learning, especially in reinforcement learning, there are efforts to introduce internal rewards such as novelty seeking / curiosity and creativity. They have a clear benefit for survival. For example, ability to imagine might be seen as poetic, but in reality it is useful for planning actions without needing to play them out first, and only later acting. A useful skill that might save one's life in a split-second decision.
- mannykannot 10y agoAs a Darwinian just-so story about why consciousness is adaptive, that is fine. As an explanation of what consciousness is and how it works, it lacks specificity.