4 ms·
Although the article mentions that many parts were bought under contracts from foreign companies (making "US technology" appear in the title), I wonder how many
by theandrewbailey 10y ago
Although the article mentions that many parts were bought under contracts from foreign companies (making "US technology" appear in the title), I wonder how many domestic parts were built using stolen trade secrets and intellectual property.
- Jtsummers 10y agoMaybe some. But if China wants to fly their aircraft in Europe or the US they need to get it past the FAA and European equivalent. The main benefit of all those US-based components, with regard to this, is that those components are largely COTS or COTS+barely bespoke and are already certified or in a state where the changes can be quickly certified. Novel aircraft systems require a lot of effort to get approval from the FAA to fly. There's little benefit here unless you're also stealing/faking that paperwork.
- pdelbarba 10y agoAnd to add to this, if a jet crashes and it's discovered that the equipment is forged (as it may likely be examined by the documented OEM resulting in some WTFs flying around in a lab somewhere) the FAA will ground the entire fleet. They would then have to re-equip the aircraft with certified electronics and possibly re-certify everything. I'd be willing to bet that in that situation, any aircraft that was owned locally would either be sold back to china/someone else who wouldn't care or scrapped costing everyone a metric shit ton of money
- pdelbarba 10y agoInitially, I doubt China would attempt this. Avionics and control systems (the only stuff worth cloning) are hard and this is just a first flight. Over time, you may see some domestic shops open up and start supplying low cost equipment as an option on production jets, but all of this tech will have to clear certification to fly anywhere in the west. I imagine various governments will probably give them a hard time in order to protect their own production lines.
- sjm-lbm 10y agoFWIW, China actually did exactly this with the Comac ARJ21 - the "smaller, regional jet" already flying that was mentioned in this article. Most groups outside China believe that the ARJ21 is produced using some manufacturing tooling that was left in China after McDonnell Douglas (now part of Boeing) ended an early 90s program to produce MD80/MD90 series aircraft in China. It's been reported that some early plans for the airplane were actually copies of McDonnell Douglas plans with the logo changed. China, of course, denies this, but the ARJ21 is very similar in design to many McDonnell Douglas aircraft.
- pdelbarba 10y agoYou bring up a good point. During the cold war, the soviet union had a lot of success just copying western airframes. While at this point A320/B737/C919 class aircraft using traditional construction have reached a design consensus, it'll be interesting to see what happens if they try composites.
- sjm-lbm 10y agoYeah, and it could also be interesting to see if they can quickly acclimate to more advanced technology. Back when the C919 launched, I read some speculation that it was built from stolen A320 plans - the dimensions are suspiciously similar. At least as I understand it, though, the current consensus is that they simply copied the size because the 320 proved the market for a plane of, more or less, exactly that size. If they can do something similar with composites - learn from/reverse engineer Airbus and Boeing composite designs, but not genuinely steal plans - they might be able to skip a fair amount of the extreme pain with composites A and B have had over the past decade.
- vermontdevil 10y agoSee Concordski
- pdelbarba 10y agoOk, maybe "success" was the wrong word to use ;) Edit: for the uninitiated, the Tu-144 was a bit of deathtrap. While it made some interesting improvements to the original design, it had numerous problems due to less advanced Soviet manufacturing.
- strictnein 10y agoA lot. As in they've been targeting Boeing, Airbus, etc for a long time now. It's still a lot of work though, even after you've stolen the information. The ability to create modern manufacturing capabilities is a lot harder to steal. British did it to the Chinese many decades earlier of course. Darjeeling tea was mostly developed by stealing the highly coveted tea secrets from China. Decades before that, America was able to greatly advance its industrial capability by stealing secrets from the UK. "Cyberspies: The Secret History of Surveillance, Hacking, and Digital Espionage" covers this pretty well. Also goes into Chinese telecom hardware that was completely stolen from Cisco, bugs and all. https://www.amazon.com/Cyberspies-History-Surveillance-Hacking-Espionage/dp/1681771543 https://www.amazon.com/Cyberspies-History-Surveillance-Hacki... The audio book is well read: http://www.audible.com/pd/History/Cyberspies-Audiobook/B01FV0BT8U http://www.audible.com/pd/History/Cyberspies-Audiobook/B01FV...