4 ms·
"[Penrose] explained that his interest in consciousness goes back to his discovery of Gödel’s incompleteness theorem while he was a graduate student at Cambridg
by mcguire 10y ago
"[Penrose] explained that his interest in consciousness goes back to his discovery of Gödel’s incompleteness theorem while he was a graduate student at Cambridge. Gödel’s theorem, you may recall, shows that certain claims in mathematics are true but cannot be proven. “This, to me, was an absolutely stunning revelation,” he said. “It told me that whatever is going on in our understanding is not computational.”"
Penrose starts from a specific conclusion, that formal systems are limited in ways that he clearly is not, and then searched for some way to explain the difference.
- drostie 10y agoThat's kind of the modus operandi of physics, I suppose. Max Planck started from a specific conclusion, that the spectrum of the Sun is limited at high frequencies in ways that Maxwell's theory clearly is not, and then searched for some way to explain the difference.
- Sean1708 10y agoThe difference being that Planck knew what the reality was (we knew what the spectrum of the sun looked like), but with consciousness we don't really know what the reality is (there is no "spectrum" of the mind for us to match).
- lodi 10y agoOkay how about Einstein then? My understanding is that he also worked backwards in order to develop his theory of Special Relativity; he was trying to "fit" a theory to a universe that presupposed that the laws of physics are the same throughout the universe, including a constant speed of light for all observers. Relativistic effects weren't known to be reality at the time this theory was proposed. Much later, scientists developed experiments to confirm relativity. Maybe we're still searching for the right theory of consciousness to know what exactly we're trying to measure?
- some_guy_there 10y ago>Relativistic effects weren't known to be reality at the time this theory was proposed. Umnn, Michelson–Morley and Maxwell equations were enough experimental evidence before Einstein. Einstein work was reconciling Mechanics to confirm with electromagnetism, and not the other way round. EDIT: Not to say there isn't some physics theory developed independent of experiments. But relativity is not a good candidate.
- computerex 10y agoLorentz transformations predate special relativity, so there was definitely work going on in this area prior to relativity.
- noam87 10y agoIf I understand this correctly, does it not imply that there is a class of statements/ideas which Penrose (or I) can deduce, but which cannot be algorithmically proved? - If so my next question is: what is an example of such a statement?
- prutschman 10y agoA sketch is presented here: http://www.iep.utm.edu/lp-argue/#SH3a http://www.iep.utm.edu/lp-argue/#SH3a
- yequalsx 10y agoThe first order Peano axioms are not categorical but are recursively enumerable. The second order axioms are categorical but not recursively enumerable. There are statements that are true in Z but not true in a non-standard model of the first order axioms. Such a true statement is not something that can't be proven true. It just can't be proven true using the first order system.