2 ms·
I certainly agree with the article's premise, that Apple has put essentially a cap on what you can earn. I don't know that this devalues software as much as peo
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I certainly agree with the article's premise, that Apple has put essentially a cap on what you can earn. I don't know that this devalues software as much as people copying does however.
Consider a couple of scenarios; in scenario 1 when someone publishes an App that is the only App of its kind available in the store. There are millions of phone/tablet users and you capture some some percentage of them and you make a few million dollars[1]. Scenario 2 is someone publishes an App in the App store, and it starts to sell well, then 15 additional people publish the exact same App in the App store and are so busy undercutting each other the price has gone down to 99 cents. But lets say this group of apps still sells reasonably well, then another 1500 people put out the same App on the store they all sell for 99 cents or are free with in game purchases. The original app creator made perhaps a few thousand dollars on the sale of the app. And all the people jumping on board made anywhere from nothing to a few thousand as well.
This isn't the first time that technology has released the creative spark in thousands more people, and as a result the market was flooded with new products that were vaguely similar. The industrial revolution had a similar effect it seems. As it became possible for more and more people to build things in a small factory or with less training and apprenticeship things got a bit out of hand and the thing that saved them was that if you patented your invention you could be assured (if you defended your invention against infringers) of a small monopoly to recoup your costs.
And if you had that sort of system today, you could invest all your time and effort and build your app and patent it and then not have to worry that hundreds of ripoff lookalikes of varying quality would dilute the market and the returns.
And yet it would be pretty silly to have a 20 year monopoly on an App that made fart sounds, but perhaps something more aligned with technology time frames like 5 years or 3 years.
The fundamental challenge is that it is always easier to 'reproduce' than to 'invent.' And if you cannot reward the inventors they won't be able to survive and we'll miss out on innovation that they might otherwise have been able to provide.
[1] Don't worry I don't think this is reality :-)