6 ms·
China's First Jet to Rival Boeing and Airbus Is Helped by U.S. Technology
- brianbreslin 10y agoThis will be interesting to see if western airlines or middle eastern airlines buy any of these planes. My guess is they will probably rely on the chinese central banks to give cushy loans to developing nations to build out their air fleets and to chinese airlines as well to build up enough demand to sustain. China could go the route of helping regional airlines in Africa for instance get the planes they otherwise couldn't afford (with chinese construction firms getting the contracts to rebuild the local airports, and other infrastructure).
- nrki 10y ago"Comac...had orders and commitments from 23 buyers for 570 aircraft as of November 2016. Other than...[GE], all are from local companies. China Eastern Airlines Corp. ... will be the first carrier to take delivery."
- nullnilvoid 10y agoChina is by far the largest aviation market in the world. They don't need other markets to succeed. If they can replace Boeing and Airbus with their home-made airplanes, that is a huge success. According to research, China needs more than $1 trillion worth of airplanes in the coming decade. That is HUGE.
- pinaceae 10y agoExpect the Chinese state to create a very friendly environment for those domestic planes. Did it in other markets, currently under way against the iPhone. Airbus and Boeing are toast in China.
- intellegacy 10y agoThey did it against Google, Facebook, and Youtube as well.
- visakanv 10y agoAs a 3rd party observer with no stake in either the US or China, I wonder how the USA would react if China was the #1 in the world economically, and exporting Facebook, Boeing, etc. I imagine we'd see some American protectionism.
- candiodari 10y agoEuhm. Not to blow your bubble, but the US is extremely flexible and open economically. Far more so than any other country on the planet. Europe is pretty inflexible, compared to the US. E.g. there is no free market for most agricultural products in the EU. And before you say it, no this is not due to US meats having hormones in them. Firstly, those taxes and rules apply to everything, whether or not produced with EU rule compliance, and secondly, there isn't even a free market within the EU for many products (e.g. wine in France. Olive oil (or other oils) in Southern Europe, ...). And of course, the EU is certainly not neutral when it comes to other products as well, e.g. Boeing vs Airbus. China is extremely INflexible and hostile to free trade, even today. VERY few commodities trade freely with China, even just taking the published import tariffs and conditions. Add to that that the Chinese state famously owns pretty much every large Chinese corporation (state owned enterprises) and it's influence and restrictions over what products are welcome in China goes above and beyond the officially published rules. So I believe a fair assumption would be that no, the US would not object too much to large Chinese companies being successful in the US. In fact, I do believe there's large scale examples of that if you search just a little bit. For a practical example of the US allowing large non-US businesses to operate freely in the US, even where it hurts local industry, you only need to look at the steel industry.
- pinaceae 10y agoThe WTO was created to prevent these shenanigans. Europe and US play ball, mostly. EU/NAFTA/CETA/TTIP all part of that leveling of the playing field. China does not play ball, at all. Literally don't give a shit about the Wests opinions or approaches to deals. Perceived in the West as cheating, but that is just a cultural viewpoint.
- LordKano 10y agoThey don't need other markets to succeed. They don't "need" those markets but they want them. It will help to solidify China's position as the third superpower. There are incentives for those African nations to help this happen as well. Beyond the local benefits of increased commerce, they are thinking about negotiating better rates for their natural resources than they currently receive from the west.
- nullnilvoid 10y agoBoeing and Airbus want those markets as well. They don't want them any less than China does.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- codewithcheese 10y agoSerious question. What is the second superpower? EU?
- LordKano 10y agoThe USSR was the second superpower. The USSR no longer exists and there isn't currently a second superpower but I think of it like spouses. If you're married and divorced twice, when you marry again you may have only one spouse but that is your third spouse.
- 10y ago
- pdelbarba 10y agoIt'll be interesting to see if they can get their first generation of airliners off the ground and operating profitably quickly enough to embrace the coming wave of next generation composite aircraft. The C919 looks to be almost entirely traditional aluminum construction but the future of transport aircraft is looking to be increasingly based on carbon composites. The problem is that the industrial processes and supply chains for aluminum vs composite aircraft are extremely dissimilar. China however may have an edge here in the future as composites are still very labor intensive to construct.
- theandrewbailey 10y agoAlthough the article mentions that many parts were bought under contracts from foreign companies (making "US technology" appear in the title), I wonder how many domestic parts were built using stolen trade secrets and intellectual property.
- Jtsummers 10y agoMaybe some. But if China wants to fly their aircraft in Europe or the US they need to get it past the FAA and European equivalent. The main benefit of all those US-based components, with regard to this, is that those components are largely COTS or COTS+barely bespoke and are already certified or in a state where the changes can be quickly certified. Novel aircraft systems require a lot of effort to get approval from the FAA to fly. There's little benefit here unless you're also stealing/faking that paperwork.
- pdelbarba 10y agoAnd to add to this, if a jet crashes and it's discovered that the equipment is forged (as it may likely be examined by the documented OEM resulting in some WTFs flying around in a lab somewhere) the FAA will ground the entire fleet. They would then have to re-equip the aircraft with certified electronics and possibly re-certify everything. I'd be willing to bet that in that situation, any aircraft that was owned locally would either be sold back to china/someone else who wouldn't care or scrapped costing everyone a metric shit ton of money
- pdelbarba 10y agoInitially, I doubt China would attempt this. Avionics and control systems (the only stuff worth cloning) are hard and this is just a first flight. Over time, you may see some domestic shops open up and start supplying low cost equipment as an option on production jets, but all of this tech will have to clear certification to fly anywhere in the west. I imagine various governments will probably give them a hard time in order to protect their own production lines.
- sjm-lbm 10y ago
- tuna-piano 10y agoWhat's the difference between Boeing, Airbus, or Comac? Boeing and Airbus: -Are owned by shareholders all over the world(including China!)[1] -Assemble planes all over the world(including China!)[2][3] -Have employees all over the world (including China!)[4] -Use parts made all over the world (including China!) [5][6] Moreover, trade is always equal[7]. If the US sends China $100 of corn and China sends back $100 of plane, who cares? ------ [1]http://www.cfr.org/united-states/quarterly-update-foreign-ownership-us-assets/p25685 http://www.cfr.org/united-states/quarterly-update-foreign-ow... [2]https://www.wsj.com/articles/boeing-identifies-site-for-china-plant-1477687939 https://www.wsj.com/articles/boeing-identifies-site-for-chin... [3] http://www.businessinsider.com/airbus-china-factory-a320-2015-8/#the-planes-117-foot-wingspan-takes-of-up-most-of-the-space-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/airbus-china-factory-a320-201... [4]https://jobs.boeing.com/location/china-jobs/185/1814991/2 https://jobs.boeing.com/location/china-jobs/185/1814991/2 [5]http://boeing.mediaroom.com/2005-06-02-Boeing-787-Highlights-600-Million-in-Contracts-with-Chinese-Suppliers http://boeing.mediaroom.com/2005-06-02-Boeing-787-Highlights... [6]http://www.businessinsider.com/graphic-boeing-787-dreamliner-suppliers-2013-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/graphic-boeing-787-dreamliner... [7]You may have heard of a "trade deficit". Well, is China sending the US $100 in products and not ask for anything in return? If so, that would obviously be amazing for the US and foolish for China (free stuff!). The truth is that instead of purchasing $100 in products to send back to China, China instead decides to purchase $100 of investment stuff in the USA, and will take the future returns that investment provides them. An example: China sends $100 of plane, takes that $100 and builds a $100 apartment building in the USA. It then takes $5 of profits a year back to China in corn, and then sells the building in 30 years for (now a larger amount) of $200 in corn.
- notahacker 10y agoDespite the globalised nature of aviation supply chains, expect to see the nearly all the C919s operate within the Chinese market (with most of the rest being developing countries in Asia). The real difference is decades of experience, development, reputation and global maintenance programme setup behind the Boeing/Airbus series, and most operators looking to acquire new aircraft won't overlook that in favour of slightly lower capital costs without a lot of encouragement and support network that's very close to their home base.
- rb808 10y agoThe market is getting busy See also Canada's Bombardier CSeries CS100 - 120 passengers. Japans Mitsubishi Regional Jet - 80 passengers. Brazil's Embraer E-Jet - 120 passengers.
- JBReefer 10y agoI'm not the world's closest observer, but those aren't perfect comparisons. The C-series nearly bankrupted Bombardier, and a lot of it's competitive advantages aren't things the market once. It's also much smaller, and frankly I've never been in a good Bombardier. There's a lot of CRJs, but they're more expensive and lower quality than ERJs. I don't think the C-series is any better. I've also dealt with Bombardier's aerospace division, and they're kind of unpleasant. Not serious competition at all. Mitsubishi - 80 pax is half of this, more in line with the E-jet. It's a regional, not a direct competitor. This is not going to run with the big boys of the DFW-LGA/ATL-ORD type flights. E-Jet - Great planes, again not the same league. The C919 carries "158-174" pax - that's a totally class of plane. The E-jet line tops out at 120, as this line is regional jets, most are smaller. Bombardier is totally fucked here, CRJ's are terrible. I think the E-Jet is going to do great. The 919 competes with the 737/320 class, which until now has been a duopoly with some TERRIBLE Russian attempts to compete.
- vultour 10y agoI wonder when we will move away from the current plane designs, they all look the same for decades now! I think a change like the one in automotive industry in the last century would be welcome. I'd personally love to see some more 'edgy' shapes with less curves (ala F-117).
- AlgorithmicTime 10y agoYou know the reason the F-117 is "edgy" is to reduce radar cross section? And that there are better ways to do that - look at the B-2, F-22, or F-35.
- pdelbarba 10y agoThere's a reason the F-117 is the only airframe that looks like that. It had the aerodynamic efficiency of a brick. The fact is, current airliners have reached a balance of a number of factors resulting in them all looking the same. Ever wonder why the old DC10 style tri-jets went out of favor? Too hard to maintain the tail engine. Concorde? Burned too much fuel, excessively high landing speed/distance (11,800 ft 0_o) because of it's short wings needed for supersonic flight. Why are there no flying wing B-2 style airliners like Popular Science prophetizes about every few years? Nowhere to put windows. Also, tubes lend themselves better to the pressurization cycles that airliners experience. The fact is, it turns out given current market constraints the optimal design is two engines, tube fuselage, narrow swept wings. Style has absolutely no influence over the economics of airline operation.
- cmurf 10y agoThe F117 is an inherently unstable aircraft, which is why it's also maneuverable. Passenger planes are designed to be dynamically and statically stable, they're harder to stall, easier to recover from a stall, are not prone to stall spins, etc. Whether the main wing or the horizontal stabilizer stalls first, the plane is recoverable (including with a failed powerplant). That's not a given with other designs. As soon as you go with a candard design, you have to ensure the canard always stalls first or you've got an unrecoverability problem. Existing designs are less complex is what it comes down to.
- ris 10y agoNews to me that technology has a nationality.