3 ms·
When your workplace distribute the software you write to their customers, what political ideology does the license force onto them?
by belorn 10y ago
When your workplace distribute the software you write to their customers, what political ideology does the license force onto them?
- watwut 10y agoWhat does that have to do with anything? OSS and tech generally likes to praise itself as more rational fact based, but demagoguery is sometimes downright ridiculous. If I distribute open source library under GPL, the advantage of GPL is supposed to be that users of my library have to provide source code to their users. Making it "viral" and preventing them to do close source business. It was written this way because of ideology authors had - treating open source as moral value.
- smichel17 10y agoThat's just the thing: software freedom does have moral value. Power imbalances are abused. That's how you end up with stuff like nsa backdoors. Software freedom helps fix the power imbalance between users and developers.
- watwut 10y agoThat is kinda like saying that letters being private make it harder to caught terrorists, so we should make it question of morality to make all letters public.
- belorn 10y agoI find it offputing when a business put people in jail because someone shared a exact copy of a program. That ideology is a large part why people put their work under gpl. As a fact, no person have ever been sent to jail for sharing a GPL'ed software with a friend. If you oppose people getting sent to jail or given fines that will last a person a life time, then it perfect rational not to help companies that do this. Some add clauses which says "do no evil", others put common legal obstacles so the practical results will be that code aren't used by them.