4 ms·
Wow, downvoted. Who could possibly think cheating is ok...
by Chris2048 10y ago
Wow, downvoted. Who could possibly think cheating is ok...
- jazoom 10y agoOkay? Maybe not. Illegal? What's the point of that?
- Chris2048 10y agoThe same point as anything, to defend individual rights and improve society. AM exploited the weakness of the people using its service. And in the context of a guy who killed himself rather than face the shame of having betrayed his wife?
- jazoom 10y agoIt sounds like the effort should go towards changing people's attitudes instead of regulating what business can do.
- Chris2048 10y agoYou could say that about any corporate legislation. There's nothing stopping you from doing both. Any effort to change attitudes will be more successful if it doesn't have to compete with corporate marketing; for example, it's easier to get people to reject tobacco, if they aren't constantly exposed to marketing making it seem cool, harmless, healthy(!?) and/or normal. Coke adds normalize casually drinking caffeinated sugar water. McDonalds even had athletes eating their burgers. There are some people who will always cheat, making it easier to hide it from their partner is the best you can do.
- jazoom 10y agoI mean change attitudes about sex. What law of the universe says people should have sex with only one person? It's not cheating if it's accepted. I think AM is a scummy company but they are only accommodating what people already want to do.
- Chris2048 10y ago> It's not cheating if it's accepted True, which means this is a tangent. For those who do commit, they shouldn't cheat. I'm not going to go into reasons for monogamy, but "what people already want to do" is cheat. Should there be no insider trading laws either? Clearly crooked traders want to cheat, so why not let them?
- jazoom 10y agoNo one loses anything in this case. In fact, if the couple is okay with it, you could consider it a gain. Your analogy isn't even close. By the way, I mean no disrespect. My way of thinking used to be more similar to yours.
- Chris2048 10y agoNo problem, but I'm not sure I follow. What is this case? We're talking about cheating, but that is specifically cheating on a commitment. A couple who are happy with an open relationship are not cheating. There are already dating sites for swingers etc, AM is not one of them, AM if specifically for cheaters. They act against the interests of the cheated-upon. This is why I made the analogy; a inside trader might be OK with it because they see the gain, but not the loss.
- jazoom 10y agoYou are right. AM does seem specifically for sneaky commitment-breaking, which is one reason I think they are scummy. I also believe it bad to cheat on a commitment. I suppose I lost my point, which was this shouldn't be illegal. Not all scumminess should be illegal since you will end up making criminals out of decent people who do a scummy thing. Road rage is bad but if everyone who succumbs to it was a criminal then half the country would have a criminal record. A better solution would be a culture change where this commitment isn't strongly pushed onto people from social pressure when it's obviously not the right thing for that person. Another better solution would be reducing social stigma around divorce.
- manyxcxi 10y agoI don't think cheetos are ok, yet I don't think it should be illegal for a company to sell them. I think it's immoral to advertise vaguely about health benefits (see how many vitamins and minerals are in Lucky Charms!) when researchers can unequivocally point to your product as directly harmful to health. I'm still not against a company's right to sell Lucky Charms. My morality doesn't belong in the laws and neither does yours. The entire history of human civilization is littered with horrible event after horrible event based in the name of someone's twisted ideas. AM created a (seemingly shitty) a place for two consenting adults to find each other and meet. That Bob or Alice are married shouldn't matter one iota, it was their informed choice. This is even better in my opinion than having a standard dating site where one party is expecting a traditional relationship only to eventually be hurt by the fact the other person was stepping out on their partner and not really interested. Cheating isn't okay with me either, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to legislate against it. Are we going to force people to start wearing scarlet letters?
- jazoom 10y agoYou said what I was thinking but in a smarter way.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThere's more to it than that. Apparently AM faked female contact info millions of times, and tried to charge for more contact with the fake accounts. Simple fraud. So not only a website that allowed immoral (in some views) activity. Actually an immoral website that perpetrated fraud and extortion.
- manyxcxi 10y agoThat was my aside about them seeming to be shitty. I think AM was a scummy company enabling people to do something I don't agree with. I'd be more than happy if they got the hammer for fraud or something, but purely for enabling immorality, hell no.