4 ms·
>4) To make a 14th amendment deprivation claim, you have to show deprivation of a property right. At the time petitioner sought his money back, he had no proper
by trhway 10y ago
>4) To make a 14th amendment deprivation claim, you have to show deprivation of a property right. At the time petitioner sought his money back, he had no property right.
yes, because he was deprived of that property right. Vacated conviction doesn't seem to satisfy "adequate process" requirements for the deprivation.
The logic of Thomas's dissent is like accepting the argument in, say for example, physical assault case that the person didn't objected to a beating because his mouth was duct-taped shut.
>You can assert that judgment against the seller to collect, but at most the judgment means the seller owes you money back, it does not automatically transfer the property right in some of the money you paid back to you.
seems you've never tried to collect on a judgement. Once you get the judgement against other party, you identify the property of that other party, say bank account or a real estate, and get a court order for the sheriff to withdraw from the account identified or an order for the county to put a lien on identified real estate of the other party. Such orders are basically orders for the transfer of the property right.