4 ms·
There weren't any public pension funds at the start of the 20th century. If we instead look at time periods during which the industry average was considered to
by vkou 10y ago
There weren't any public pension funds at the start of the 20th century.
If we instead look at time periods during which the industry average was considered to be 8%...
https://dqydj.com/dow-jones-return-calculator/ https://dqydj.com/dow-jones-return-calculator/
1960-1990 = 9.5% average return.
1960-2000 = 11.5% average return.
It's largely pointless to talk about inflation-unadjusted average-rate-of-return for long time periods. A 12% YoY return when inflation is at 15% is terrible. A 5% YoY return when inflation is at 0% is amazing.
- EternalData 10y agoYou're overfitting. This is exactly the problem I'm describing. Case in point, you've omitted 2000-2010. Real (CPI as inflation) averaged annualized return on the DJIA 2000-2010: -2.219% This is with relatively mild inflation. Of course, 1960-2000 looks better when you literally put in the apex of the software bubble when P/E ratios shot skywards...part of which corrected over the decade following. Expecting a 8% nominal or real return is simply nuts in my opinion because you are staking yourself on a really small sample size with crazy inflation to boot. Nominal or real is a nuanced distinction to what is plainly just bad overfit thinking. The introduction of just one decade with low inflation and bad returns can wreck you -- case in point: Dallas Firefighters/Puerto Rico ($43bn + of unfunded pension obligations)/Detroit etc. etc. etc.
- EternalData 10y agoAlso, to add another wrinkle to this discussion, most pension funds won't weight themselves 100% in stocks (corresponding positions in cash/bonds average much lower real or nominal return), and most pay significant management/consulting fees on top...
- vkou 10y agoWere pension fund managers in 2010 predicting 8% growth? I have my doubts about that.