6 ms·
Puerto Rico should really be a state by now. Would it being a state given it any distinct advantages (or are there any specific problems in light of it not bein
by djsumdog 10y ago
Puerto Rico should really be a state by now. Would it being a state given it any distinct advantages (or are there any specific problems in light of it not being a state) in this type of situation?
- pboutros 10y agoCities and states have access to debt restructuring methods (per this article), which PR does not. http://www.cnbc.com/2015/12/01/crunch-time-for-puerto-rico-debt-crisis.html http://www.cnbc.com/2015/12/01/crunch-time-for-puerto-rico-d...
- desdiv 10y agoStates do not have access to chapter 9 bankruptcy. If Puerto Rico were a state then it would not have the bankruptcy protections that it currently enjoys right now. Things would be much much worst for them in that case.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoI think the point is that the states, being states, are in the same situation as the federal government is. They can tell creditors to go *k themselves. And then both sides get to bear the consequences. In truth, something similar is true for local governments as well, in practice.
- ch4s3 10y agoThey would have been able to filibuster and stop congress from removing the pharma subsidy that then resulted in pharma companies fleeing the island. This in turn lead to the underfunding of pensions and general budget shortfalls on the island. So... maybe they'd have made out better as a state. Who know though, they had all their eggs in 2 baskets basically.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Puerto Rico should really be a state by now. Would it being a state given it any distinct advantages (or are there any specific problems in light of it not being a state) in this type of situation? In the narrow sense, traditional municipal bankruptcy would have been available to it in this situation (and creditors would have acted with that knowledge, which would likely have forestalled it getting to the current situation) were that the case. More broadly, PR would have greater influence in federal policy were it a state with voting representation in Congress and electoral votes for the Presidency, which would also make it less likely that things would have gotten this bad.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Puerto Rico should really be a state by now. Would it being a state given it any distinct advantages (or are there any specific problems in light of it not being a state) in this type of situation? Puerto Rico's economy has been crippled by the Jones Act, which affects all US states/territories that rely solely on sea transportation for trade with the US. Hawaii is the only state that fits that description, and they've also been suffering deeply due to the Jones Act, although not as badly as Puerto Rico (for reasons due to the specifics of Hawaii's economy, not its statehood).
- giancarlostoro 10y agoJones Act and a couple of other things: https://www.bna.com/demise-puerto-rico-n57982074653/ https://www.bna.com/demise-puerto-rico-n57982074653/ Used to be that Puerto Rico was once upon a time #1 in manufacturing, Japan was #2. The USA and England followed. Something to think about. Puerto Rico exports out of the US more pharmaceuticals than California currently, or at least it did in 2015[0]. There's so much potential for Puerto Rico. We also have a lot of engineers in NASA (or did?) because they go to Puerto Rico to hire engineering students if I remember correctly from Mayaguez. So much potential and it's sad to see it go to waste, I think all Puerto Ricans are to blame as much the people as the politicians. We all always blame politicians but as a people we don't do enough. [0]: http://www.puertoricoreport.com/puerto-rico-leads-pharmaceutical-exports/#.WQsV89ryuUl http://www.puertoricoreport.com/puerto-rico-leads-pharmaceut...
- chimeracoder 10y ago> I think all Puerto Ricans are to blame as much the people as the politicians. We all always blame politicians but as a people we don't do enough. I can't think of a single thing Puerto Ricans could reasonably and legally do that would have fixed this problem. The inability to import/export things at reasonable rates has crippled the economy, and nothing short of federal policy changes (which Puerto Ricans cannot directly influence, short of moving to the mainland) would impact those fundamental economic realities.
- 10y ago
- appetizer 10y agoIf a real challenge was made to Puerto Rico's territory status since the US conservatorship was based on racist premises, wouldn't it be more likely to get kicked out of the union than assigned statehood? At least by Supreme Court analysis of the constitutionality of the conservatorship. I suppose if that happened there would be immediately enough consensus to gain statehood from both Puerto Ricans and US Congress.
- jcranmer 10y agoYes, being a state would solve some of these fiscal issues. It's even been discussed for the past few years that this debt situation might be the thing that pushes Puerto Rico to actually become a state. The major problem is that Puerto Ricans don't actually want to become a state. In the various referendums, the majority generally goes for status quo, followed by statehood, followed by independence. In 2012, the referendum was more or less connived to produce a vote for statehood (it was structured as two questions, the first "status quo or not" and the second "state, free association, or complete independence"). There's apparently another referendum scheduled in a month, but I've not found any polling on what the likelihood of success for statehood is in that referendum.
- leesalminen 10y agoI was in San Juan last month and spoke with ~12 people on the topic. It was roughly an even split between statehood and status quo. Many anticipated a declaration of insolvency and figured statehood was the best fix for the problem.
- mgbmtl 10y agoJust curious: what's the main argument against statehood? Federal taxes?
- mooseburger 10y agoPuerto Rican here. Basic dignity I think. We should be an independent country, but most Puerto Ricans are frightened of independence.
- Animats 10y agoThere's a statehood faction, an independence faction, and a big "don't upset the gravy train" faction that likes the status quo. If Puerto Rico became a state, US Federal personal income taxes would be imposed. If Puerto Rico became an independent country, immigration to the US would be stopped. There have been referendums on this. The next one is June 11, 2017.
- kchoudhu 10y agoI know a very wealthy hedge fund manager who just moved to PR in order to minimize (read: eliminate) his Federal tax burden. Of course, as the current situation demonstrates, not being under the Federal taxation umbrella has certain disadvantages.
- zeroer 10y agoWait. I though Puerto Ricans were only exempt from federal income tax on Pueto Rican-sourced income.
- dustinmr 10y agoHere's a local law where if you meet all the criteria (income made off the island, spend > 180 days per year here, various other criteria), you're exempt from income taxes here. And since you're a resident, all your income is here. Effectively exempting you from federal income taxes. The idea was to attract high net worth individuals to spend money here. Every analysis I've seen says it has worked quite well.
- martinald 10y agoCrazy. So if you move to PR but making money from other US based interests you get exempted from US federal income tax, but if you move and work permentantly in say Germany, you still get charged US Federal Income tax?
- enraged_camel 10y ago