4 ms·
I worry about passive investing. Does it turn into winner take all? If most everyone puts there money in a index tracker it would go up or down based on contri
by sharemywin 10y ago
I worry about passive investing. Does it turn into winner take all?
If most everyone puts there money in a index tracker it would go up or down based on contribution and withdraw rates versus actual results of the market.
So, while there is more contributing than withdrawing it continues to go up which would attract more money to it.
- politicalthrow 10y agoIndex funds are therefore the next bubble?
- maerF0x0 10y agoor maybe public investable assets? Too much money chasing too small a pool of assets? There are also a lot of private assets that could be superior investments, but average folks do not have access to.
- sharemywin 10y agoAssumptions: * index funds are larger and larger share of investing * Median Baby boomer about 63 * 1/2 Americans in stock market * In 2017, over 62 million Americans receive SS benefits * US Adult Population 247,773,709 = 123M in stock market * Only 25 M generation X * Millennials don't invest in stocks http://www.businessinsider.com/why-so-few-millennials-invest-in-the-stock-market-2016-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/why-so-few-millennials-invest... Conclusion Drain of stock market as sellers begin to out number buyers
- dbjacobs 10y agoThis ignores just how skewed towards the rich stock ownership is. The liquidation of stocks owned by the middle class will not move the needles much. And the very rich don't need to liquidate their stocks to maintain their lifestyle.
- maerF0x0 10y agoPassive investing is nice, but I have seen few good articles about drawing down when retirement actually hits.
- austenallred 10y agoI don't worry about that at all. The risk is that there is so much in index funds that the valuations of companies will become distanced form what they're actually worth. The likelihood of that happening given how much money there is to be made in finding the inefficiencies in the stock market are, in my opinion, very small.