3 ms·
For the most part, people getting Medicaid under Medicaid expansion don't have any assets to speak of and won't owe the government anything for services they re
by maxerickson 10y ago
For the most part, people getting Medicaid under Medicaid expansion don't have any assets to speak of and won't owe the government anything for services they receive under Medicaid (they are the "working poor").
It certainly is the case that the nursing home care paid for by Medicaid is intended to be a last resort, after other resources are exhausted. So of course it examines other resources.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoI am sorry, you are sadly misinformed. See this chart: http://kff.org/medicaid/state-indicator/medicaid-enrollment-by-age/?currentTimeframe=0&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22:%22Location%22,%22sort%22:%22asc%22%7D http://kff.org/medicaid/state-indicator/medicaid-enrollment-... Here are a few examples of people under the age of 26 who are on Medicaid: California, 57% Colorado, 69% Idaho, 73% Wyoming, 75% etc. The only way your assertion is true is if these are worthless and will never make anything out of their lives. Which, of course, isn't true at all. And so, a young person is shoved into Medicaid and convinced they have medical insurance when, in reality, they are accumulating debt with the government. And, yes, as life goes on they see some success perhaps buy a house and have an investment or two and never realize the hook that got sunk and set into them when they were younger. In California alone well over six million people under 27 years of age are walking around thinking they have medical insurance. Even if this wasn't the case, let's turn things around a bit. Say an insurance company, Nefarious Unlimited, was issuing medical insurance policies --real insurance-- with a hidden clause in them. The minute the insurance buyer signs on the dotted line Nefarious Unlimited is given the right to recover 100% of their costs from the persons estate. As little or as much as they might have. Of course, Nefarious Unlimited does not inform their customers that the product they are buying is actually a loan rather than real medical insurance. They even go on TV to advertise it and tout the millions of "satisfied customers" they have. Nefarious Unlimited would be brought-up on fraud charges so fast your head would spin. The entire board and management would probably --and rightly so-- end-up in jail. Nobody would argue with this outcome. You see, whether or not a person has a large estate this is wrong, fraudulent and immoral. That is the point you are missing in addition to the above. This is our government engaged in fraud of the worst kind. This should not be OK with anyone. This isn't about political lines. This is about basic human decency and exists at the most basic levels of right and wrong.
- maxerickson 10y agoThere's no recovery mechanism for younger people, they get services and that's it. There's income and asset tests that happen before services are delivered. You need to carefully reexamine who the asset recovery provisions actually apply to. Among other things, it'd save you time writing lengthy comments about your mistaken conclusion.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoI have read all of it and then some. I have even spent money to consult with three different attorneys on the subject as my family became concerned about how this mechanism would affect our parent's estate. You can find various corner cases where Medicaid estate recovery isn't an issues. Yes. Yet this is NOT reality for the vast majority of those being shoved into the program by the tens of millions. I am very well informed on this front, having sought the advice of top attorneys in this domain. This is very real. You can choose to study the links I provided and educate yourself or reject it while armed with imperfect information. In the end reality isn't modified. We'll probably start seeing the effects of this during the next twenty years. Maybe then people will wake up.
- maxerickson 10y agoOlder people mostly get health benefits from Medicare. Medicaid is intended to be a further benefit for people that have low incomes. It's only surprising that it examines an estate if you don't understand that it isn't designed to be anything more than a benefit of last resort. Sure, you can't have Medicaid pay for your parents care and also keep their estate. But this isn't mind blowing information, it's the way the law was designed to work and something anyone involved in estate planning would know off hand.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoYou really need to do a bunch of research and reading. Here's a tid-bit: Quote: "Does Medicare Pay For Long Term Care? NO. After a 3 day hospital stay, Medicare pays 100% of the cost, but only for the first 20 days of skilled nursing care. For days 21 through 100, you are responsible for a co-payment. As of this date, the daily co-pay rate is $148 per day. But it gets worse: After 100 days of care in a nursing home, Medicare stops paying altogether, and you are responsible for all future costs, unless there is a new 3 day qualifying hospital stay (which then re-sets the 100 day clock). You also need to be aware that Medicare does not pay for “custodial care.” If you or a loved one are in need of custodial care, it must be paid for either by writing a check, by private long-term care insurance, or by Medi-Cal." I am not going to bother providing you with links because you are obviously not reading anything. If you are truly interested in understanding the issues you need to spend half a day googling around to build a better image of what reality looks like. Also, my wife is a doctor. She, among other things, has dealt with precisely the segment "served" by all of these programs for at least ten years. She has left that practice. And so have tons of doctors. This is the other side of the equation. These programs work for some but, on the aggregate, they are a disaster. It is impossible for doctors to provide good care. Patients are getting screwed right and left. My wife would easily see a dozen patients a week for free because there was no possible way to justify doing it under these programs. The vast majority of people are extremely ignorant of the realities in US health care. Anyhow, that's the end of it. Thanks.