3 ms·
We don't have strong national standards because it's not in the purview of the Federal government to regulate gun sales or licensing. It is explicitly up to the
by pc86 10y ago
We don't have strong national standards because it's not in the purview of the Federal government to regulate gun sales or licensing. It is explicitly up to the states to do within the bounds of the Second Amendment.
Flying a plane is not a Constitutional right (I am finishing my PPL now, actually!), and is under the Federal government's regulatory authority.
- winter_blue 10y agoIn 2010, the SCOTUS found that the right to bear arms (the Second Amendment) is incorporated by the 14th amendment against the states: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonald_v._City_of_Chicago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonald_v._City_of_Chicago So states have restricted power and authority to regulate or restrict your freedom to bear arms. Now, regarding flying... If we ignore the machine used to travel / the mode of transportation (be it a plane, a car, a space saucer, etc) -- the basic question we're asking here is: do the people have a travel freely within their country regardless of what machine or contraption they use to do so? A basic analysis of the constitution would reveal that the right to travel freely (using whatever contraption or machine to do so) was something so obviously a right, that it did not require to be explicitly stated as a protected right (and likely implicitly covered under the 9th). Imagine states in 1800, requiring licensing (i.e. government approval) before you could ride a horse. There would've been an uproar.
- pc86 10y agoThe specificity is important. I am talking specifically about operating general aviation aircraft. A good portion of GA flight is not travel from A to B but sight-seeing/recreation. The question isn't whether travel is a Constitutional right. The question is whether it's a violation of your Constitutional rights to require training and licensure to operate a single-engine piston aircraft. It's not.
- zeveb 10y ago> Flying a plane is not a Constitutional right (I am finishing my PPL now, actually!), and is under the Federal government's regulatory authority. Which enumerated power in the Constitution grants the United States the ability to regulate intrastate flight?
- scaryspooky 10y agoBy the same reasoning that the federal government can regulate crop production even if the specific product isn't sold between states (Wickard v. Filburn). I'm sure the same argument could be crafted that intrastate flights affect interstate flight prices, surely this is how the argument would be framed.
- ryanwaggoner 10y agoI'm well aware. That is unrelated to how I think it's crazy.