4 ms·
I wonder how long this will matter. When we're all living in shared studio apartments in car-free megacities, will there still be interest in going places whose
by closeparen 10y ago
I wonder how long this will matter. When we're all living in shared studio apartments in car-free megacities, will there still be interest in going places whose whole appeal is being out of mass transit range? Will we still own camping and hunting gear?
Maybe the support will be there to maintain public lands and National Parks, but what about the roads and necessary roadside businesses (gas, motels, restaurants, etc) leading up to them?
Will rental cars be economical when leisure is the only remaining use of the automobile?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eagletusk 10y agoHuman's that acquire more leisure time are going to want to stay in the city more and more? I feel the opposite trend will happen. I live in a outdoor industry bubble in Boulder Colorado so I have blinders on perhaps.
- matt4077 10y agoI live in an apartment, in a Megacity[0], and none of my friends have cars[1]. I see no reason to suspect that city life diminishes interest in nature. If anything, it's more of an experience because it's different. Come summer, my Facebook feed is filled with nature, and I've personally crossed the Alps on bicycle, usually camping the forests at night. Upkeep of a few roads isn't actually that expensive, and to some degree costs are proportional to use. Take a look at a map of Australia to see many roads that may only see a few cars per week. Even if a National Park were only accessible by gravel road, I'd argue it'd enhance the experience. With regards to cars, I get the sense that the most realistic future is no longer mass-transit only, but includes self-driving electric car-sharing. That allows people to continue enjoying the benefits of individual cars (privacy, carrying stuff, direct point-to-point, use of existing infrastructure worth billions) while still enabling the kind of transformation previously attributed to mass transit. For example, autonomous driving and car-sharing reduces the need for parking spaces and allows parking spaces to move to less-desirable areas, freeing up 1/3 of your typical city street. [0]: Using a rather technical definition of ≥1 Million inhabitants [1]: Yes, I have friends.
- jpetso 10y agoI'm having a hard time seeing autonomous vehicles significantly undercutting the price of existing rental cars, which is definitely something that keeps me from getting out of town on a regular basis. Sure, renting for a long weekend is still significantly cheaper than actually owning a car, but compared to other costs (taking a walk to the closest inner-city park, cycling to a larger one, or just having dinner or board games with friends) it's actually a pretty high threshold. What I am looking forward to is the night heating feature that allow electric cars to function as a makeshift "hotel room" for overnight accommodation. Once I have access to that via carsharing, that should lower the cost of a weekend trip enough to do it on a regular basis, with no camping gear required.
- brewdad 10y agoAlternatively, I would like to see some sort of workable car-sharing solution that would allow me to head out to the wilderness and hike for a few days without having to pay rental fees for the time my car sits unused at the trailhead. I only need the car for 8 hours or so (4 hour drive there and back) but have to pay for 96 hours of use.
- jpetso 10y agoYeah, that should be much more feasible once the car can drive back to a more populated area for rental use there, until it takes off to pick you up from the trailhead again. I like this line of thinking as well! Higher mileage but also a higher degree of utilization, hopefully leading to less cars being needed overall.
- cr0sh 10y ago> With regards to cars, I get the sense that the most realistic future is no longer mass-transit only, but includes self-driving electric car-sharing. I see this as likely too, but I also can see the downsides to it, because people suck. Just think of how mass transit looks like in your city, and how people treat rental cars, rented housing, etc - and apply that to shared vehicles. Though to be honest, we could make a better comparison today to things like Zipcar; I've never used one, so I don't know how often - if at all - one climbs into a car only to find it beaten to hell and back with vomit in the seats? Then again, such services aren't ubiquitous in all cities, so fewer people use them, and they might be more expensive so that those with a worse sense in using other's property are less likely to use the service? I just know that with rental cars ("drive it like you rented it") and rental properties - it's hit or miss whether the renter(s) are going to be careful with the property and upkeep of it, or if they are going to utterly destroy it (usually, it's probably somewhere in-between, tending toward taking care of it). You'll always have those outliers I guess. For now, though, I am keeping my vehicles, and paying the price. For one, I can't easily rent what I own (both vehicles are four-wheel drive and designed for off-roading), and one of those vehicles is a fairly rare machine (only about 5000 were sold in the United States). There are times, though, that I have been thankful I could rent a vehicle or take a cab or similar; sometimes you have no choice, or it's the better thing to do for the purpose at hand. In the future, with self-driving shared vehicles, this will be welcome for many purposes - but there will be downsides (likely, the first person to get the "destroyed vehicle" would decline it with a reason and it would be sent back to a depot for refurbishment).
- mason240 10y agoI agree completly. Not having a car or space for camping gear is a huge barrier to getting outdoors. Imagine two groups of people: 1000 suburbanites with SUVs and garages, and 1000 urban apartment dwellers with no car at all. Which group is going to have more hikers, hunters, campers, fishers, ect?
- s73ver 10y agoPlaces like REI, where one can rent camping equipment for a reasonable price, exist.
- closeparen 10y agoOnce you've rented camping gear, what do you do with it? Remember, the plan is that neither the REI nor your apartment would have any parking. Haul it on the bus?
- mason240 10y agoSure, but it's another barrier. Every time you put a group of people though a barrier, you lose some.
- soundwave106 10y agoThe long term trend for national parks over the last 100 years has been increasingly upward: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-national-parks-have-never-been-more-popular/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-national-parks-have... -- it seems like the only dips in visitation occur during times of economic depression or war. The most extensive survey I could find on outdoor activity (http://www.outdoorfoundation.org/pdf/ResearchParticipation2016Topline.pdf http://www.outdoorfoundation.org/pdf/ResearchParticipation20...) seems to indicate that, while popularity of individual activities varies, the participation rate seems to have been roughly the same overall for a decade, at least. Maybe hunting and camping will decline a little bit in importance, as it seems to be doing over the long term on this survey. But others might take its place. On this survey, it seems like day hiking, kayaking, BMX biking, and trail running / adventure racing made some significant gains over the last ten years, for instance. The main thing I can see autonomous cars doing is improving the park experience overall, by easing the traffic congestion in the most popular parks.