5 ms·
> During the mid-1980s, before anyone thought of the suburbs as being on a downward trajectory ... Those of us paying attention knew in the late 70s that subur
by mirimir 10y ago
> During the mid-1980s, before anyone thought of the suburbs as being on a downward trajectory ...
Those of us paying attention knew in the late 70s that suburbs were a dumb idea.
Edit: OK, so "dumb idea" unpacks to ecologically destructive, racist, socially disruptive, and fundamentally incompatible with energy and resource efficiency.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoEfficiency is not the goal of human life. Why not put everybody in a dormitory and feed them gruel? You could even run the bunks on three shifts. That would be efficient, right?
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago"Efficiency" in this case means that an economic asset can generate returns which exceed its costs.
- mirimir 10y agoYes. And said costs include negative externalities that I mentioned.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoWhy don't individual apartments have more "negative externalities" than a room full of bunks?
- mirimir 10y agoSure, that would be efficient, in a limited sense. But not if you included quality of life in the calculation. Or even productivity. And mainly, it's a dubious reductio ad absurdum.
- hueving 10y agoQuality of life is subjective. There are people that think cities are absolutely oppressive due to the crowds. Similar to how you would feel about sharing a bunk.
- mirimir 10y agoPeople think many things. But reality may end up trumping all that. Edit: What I mean is that, if negative externalities of energy and resource use were priced in, most people couldn't afford to live in the suburbs. Or at least, not in the manner that they've been accustomed to.
- yourwrong 10y agoThat will only result in higher rents in the city because you didn't address the root cause: lack of housing supply
- mirimir 10y agoWe could have built more housing in cities. And upgraded public transportation.
- someguydave 10y ago>What I mean is that, if negative externalities of energy and resource use were priced in, You say so. Gasoline is cheap and roads need not be first class to support travel.
- mirimir 10y agoGasoline is cheap only because negative externalities aren't part of the price. If global climate change stays on the current path, that could lead to a considerable increase in fossil fuel prices.
- mvindahl 10y ago> if negative externalities of energy and resource use were priced in, most people couldn't afford to live in the suburbs Depending upon the definition of "negative externalities", this may be true for most of the developed world. Maybe the Amish were right after all ..