4 ms·
Very nice setup, but he didn't show he couldn’t tell the difference between tap and the Soma water. A biased subject who can pick out both untreated water and
by Someone 10y ago
Very nice setup, but he didn't show he couldn’t tell the difference between tap and the Soma water.
A biased subject who can pick out both untreated water and Soma-filtered water from the other variants could lie about that, and claim that untreated water and Soma water taste the same.
As a thought experiment, assume the variants are plain water, orange juice, and beer. A biased subject could easily claim orange juice and water taste the same and look the same, and are easily distinguished from beer.
Also, but minor: this is about taste. Such experiments typically are done in the dark, to rule out an effect of how the water looks on taste judgments.
- crazygringo 10y agoIf you think he's lying he could have made up the entire blog post too... :P But more seriously, how would you suggest designing an experiment that worked even with liars determined to thwart it?
- ghayes 10y agoYou don't need biased subjects to have ambiguous results. Suppose for instance all people from group A can taste chlorine at 20ppm, and below that threshold, those individuals have no perceived chlorine taste. Individuals from group B can taste chlorine only at 80ppm and above. If the tap water has chlorine starting at 100ppm and the filter removed half (as stated in the article) then we would have water at 100ppm and 50ppm. Some observers would perceive a difference and some would not. If the Pur filter removed 90% of chlorine, then individuals in both groups would perceive a difference in taste. To point, this experiment depends on your taste preferences, as the author has stated that there is a physical difference in the makeup of the water samples after filtration.
- averagewall 10y agoHe would have to convince his wife who participated in it, so he can't lie about everything. To her, he can pretend two water types taste the same when really they don't, but he can't pretend the opposite. He can also lie to himself with subconscious bias. The point of blinding is that you can suffer from this even if you're trying to be honest.
- averagewall 10y agoI agree about the risk of bias. If he cheated, even subconsiously, on the tap vs Soma test, the results are consistent with bottled and Soma being indistinguishable. Which is the opposite conclusion. The suspicious inability to distinguish bottled water from Soma agrees with this. He wouldn't be able to cheat on that test if he actually couldn't tell the difference, but could cheat on tap vs Soma like you said about water and orange juice. If he didn't even know which two types he was comparing, that would protect from that kind of bias. However, from the setup, it looks like he does know.