I was replying to his post in traditional bottom-posting order, not taking his words out of sequence. It wasn't an argument about pronouns, just noting that Mr

I was replying to his post in traditional bottom-posting order, not taking his words out of sequence. It wasn't an argument about pronouns, just noting that Mr. Wisenberg's gender is known. And my substantive point remains, I think, unaddressed. My comment was on-topic. The responses to it (to include my own follow-ups) were off-topic, but my comment was on-topic.