7 ms·
This is why politics is important, even in tech. We need some grownups to represent us. If you spend ~$50/month on home internet access, and $50/month on cell
by epistasis 10y ago
This is why politics is important, even in tech.
We need some grownups to represent us.
If you spend ~$50/month on home internet access, and $50/month on cell phone access, that's $1200/year for internet connectivity.
How much do you spend on hardware per year? Do you buy a >$1200 laptop per year? How much money does Google make off of your info?
The ISPs are rolling in cash. They have terrible customer service. They typically have no competition in their markets and they refuse to innovate.
Yet, we give ISPs soooo much money. If there was proper competition, would we be spending such ridiculously high fees on the internet access we get?
- mikhailt 10y agoWasn't there a bill back in 80s/90s to pay the ISPs to modernize the grid with 100mbps across the entire country? Politics isn't the sole problem, lobbying in the company interests instead of the customers is the other problem. There has to be strict federal laws to outlaw lobbying and any type of incentives for all federal employees including the politicians. No gifting, no promises for the future (job), and so on. If such an occasion has occurred, both sides must be punished and the company must be stripped of its ability to do business in the country. The politician must be banned from holding the office and any company that they were involved with for life. How about we start with removing all free healthcare from the congress, they pay the same as the rest of us and they must go through the healthcare system just like us. If they have a problem, fracking fix it.
- MrFantastic 10y agoThe public paid for the ISP infrastructure via Tax credits we should own it.
- arca_vorago 10y agoWhat lots of people don't know is many ISPs across the country took that money and shoved it in exec pockets and then raised rates and never invested in infrastructure. An exec of one in my area for example was caught embezzling millions of that grant money.
- jonomw 10y agoDo you have a source that shows their misuse of funds? I don't believe it to be wrong, I have parroted this fact many times myself. But I just realised that I don't have any evidence of it either.
- ethbro 10y agoDifferent topic, but on the legal side of the law you'll find that most exclusive franchise agreements by an ISP contain something to the effect of "we will pay the city/county $A, give them an ongoing amount of $B/yr (and are not allowed to break that out as a line item), and perform C, D, and E at no cost." All these agreements are public. Go down to your local city hall or courthouse and ask for a copy of the franchise agreement. Point being, part of the evil is Comcast. The other part is your elected local politicians...
- pseudalopex 10y agoFranchise agreements can't be exclusive anymore. Officials at any level can still play favorites, of course.
- ethbro 10y agoI stand corrected. I'd read ours recently, as I was curious. It was essentially an inherited document from the first cable company to build a network for the city. It specifically noted it was non-exclusive, but I assumed that was the exception rather than the rule.
- deelowe 10y agoLike most things, what really happened is complicated. Here's a good hn thread on the matter. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556 If you have more interest in understanding the issue, there's plenty of good assessments. Everything from the explosion of wireless, to hdtv, to local municipalities, to mergers, and technological limitations are to blame.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rhino369 10y ago>Wasn't there a bill back in 80s/90s to pay the ISPs to modernize the grid with 100mbps across the entire country? No, it's a popular uban legend based on a misunderstanding of agreements between telecoms and the government. A telecom, IIRC Verizon, promised to upgrade their network to 45mbps access across their footprint. People are now interpreting that to mean they promised to build build a FTTH residential network (capable of 45mbps) to each home for prices similar to what you pay for DSL or cable internet. But that is a total misread. Really, Verizon was promising to upgrade their Trunk lines (T-Carrier) from T1 to T3. A T3 line is 44.736 Mbit/s. And they weren't promising to deliver a trunk line to each house for 60 bucks a month. They were expecting to charge thousands a month. This was basically a service for businesses and datacenters. Not for residential use. And they actually did do that upgrade.
- aaronchall 10y agoAnd we need competition if they think they can start throttling our Internet based on the source. I signed up with my internet provider on the assumption that all traffic would be treated equally, and I will be very upset if I notice degradation in service because I'm not using my connection in a preferred way.
- ubernostrum 10y agoThis is why politics is important, even in tech. I will keep saying it until people believe me: you can't separate out "politics". Overwhelmingly, whether people think something is "politics" (or "political" or "politicized") is reliably predicted solely by whether it affects them or people they identify with, rather than any kind of Platonically-ideal classification of topics.
- drdaeman 10y agoI don't know about the US, but it surely can't be like even greediest ISPs are not having any expenses and just hoarding cash enjoying their monopolies. Even though customers sometimes feel that way. I believe the following must be true for every ISP on the planet. Hardware crashes and/or dies - power surges, thunderstorms, vandalism, firmware bugs, old age, human errors - all sorts of stuff happen almost daily. It also has to be updated to match with ever-growing bandwidth and latency requirements. The same goes about the software parts as well, although when designed right and working solid it normally doesn't need updates - except for new features - for quite a while. Either way, all that stuff normally requires a reasonably big number of engineers and technicians, always busy either fixing things or building new stuff without introducing any actual innovation (just connecting new customers). I'm not justifying $50/mo tag (honestly, I have no idea how overpriced it is, although I guess with a proper competition it would be significantly less), just saying that maintaining the real-world (=a world where all sort of stuff that shouldn't be happens on a regular basis) network must cost significant amount.
- tdb7893 10y agoLooks at the profits for comcast and time-warner. Last time I checked (admittedly a few years ago) they were really high, especially considering how much people generally hate them
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 10y agoIt's not like people are demanding universal free internet so I'm not sure what point you're attempting to make.
- rayiner 10y ago> How much money does Google make off of your info? Alphabet's net income in 2016 was $19.5 billion, as much as Comcast and Verizon put together. Alphabet's return on invested capital and operating margins were significantly higher than either. There are various reasons to regulate ISPs, but "they make too much money" isn't a particularly good one: http://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/a-long-term-look-at-roic http://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corp... (telecom ROIC is among the lowest of any industry). > If there was proper competition, would we be spending such ridiculously high fees on the internet access we get? Is Google in a market with "proper competition?"
- epistasis 10y agoGoogle isn't one of the major internet providers here, whether Google's business has proper competition or not is not my point. My point is that we pay ISPs as much as we pay for the rest of the computing infrastructure, that they are a major player, with tons of money and high profits, and terrible service. That they aren't acting like the big boys, even though they have the cash to. ISPs are currently entrenched without competition. The current FCC fudges stats to wrongly state that there is competition in the ISP space, whereas in reality almost nobody has more than one broadband option.
- rayiner 10y agoThe point is that they're not particularly profitable in comparison to Google, even though in theory Google plays in competitive markets while ISPs are "entrenched without competition."
- anigbrowl 10y agoSo what? That doesn't obviate the possibility that their profits are maintained through corruption.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- tn135 10y ago> The ISPs are rolling in cash. Common myth. - Comcast made merely $2B in profits last year.[verified] - ATT made around $5B from wireline data last year. [unverified] A lot of people think these are monopolies with the help of government without realising that a lot of companies including Google tried to bring disruption and have failed. Part of the reason why not many people are wasting their capital on wireline is because it is unlikely to give better results. ISPs have terrible customer service because most of their efforts are going into keeping those wires and fibres intact. I would rather have a good working internet service and a bad call center rep than opposite. Not to mention when you don't allow companies like Comcast etc. to bring cheaper labor from India, they will be forced to spend more hiring American college grads and spend more cash on their training etc. We have to pay for it in the bill.
- forgotmysn 10y ago> merely $2B in profits last year I've never seen billions of dollars in profits dismissed so casually. >ISPs have terrible customer service because most of their efforts are going into keeping those wires and fibres intact. ISP's in other countries, even ones of similar scale to the US, don't have to chose between quality customer service and quality internet service. To call your argument facile would be overly generous.
- jdminhbg 10y ago> I've never seen billions of dollars in profits dismissed so casually. Comcast has around 25 million customers [0], so that's around $65/year/customer. So if you cut that profit to $0, you can return $5/month on combined TV and internet to each customer. When people say "cable and internet are so expensive," they don't generally mean "if I got a $5 price cut I would be happy." [0]: http://expandedramblings.com/index.php/comcast-statistics/ http://expandedramblings.com/index.php/comcast-statistics/
- forgotmysn 10y agoI'm not suggesting that fast, consistent internet service is cheap to provide. However, I'm also not convinced that comcast's prices aren't as high as they are, and their margins as low as they are, only because its a costly service to provide. It's also because they are really bad at providing it. But that wasn't even my main point. My point is that Comcast is more interested in providing a return to their shareholders than they in providing effective and satisfying customer service.