3 ms·
I'm pretty sure none of the futurists who believe in uploading themselves into a computer expect to do it by completely simulating a brain on the quantum level.
by jerf 10y ago
I'm pretty sure none of the futurists who believe in uploading themselves into a computer expect to do it by completely simulating a brain on the quantum level. Indeed, that would in some sense miss the point since that would accurately simulate all the degeneration a human biological brain would experience, in which case why bother?
Secondly, I think there's an implicit definition that a "full simulation" is equal to "fully understanding something", but that's not the case. For any non-trivial process, we say we "understand" it if we have a cognitively-tractable simplified model that works well enough for our use case. "Understanding" almost never implies that we have the ability to fully simulate it. I "understand" quite a lot of computer technologies without the ability to simply sit down and spew out an implementation of them with no further thought but my already-existing understanding; nevertheless, I "understand" them well as evidenced by my ability to harness them thoroughly and effectively.
And for the other direction, the mere ability to produce vast quantities of data does not mean that we have "understanding", either. You can give me the source code for a large simulation [1], say a weather prediction program, and you can give me the incoming data, and in principle I could manually compute that entire program one step at a time, but at the end I still might not "understand" anything I just produced. On its own, even if we were handed a computer system that did have a full simulation of a neuron in it that still would not grant us "understanding" of a neuron; it would grant us a tool that we might be able to use to obtain understanding, but it would not itself be "understanding".
So the literal facts in the essay are interesting, the historical perspective is interesting, the observation that full simulation of the physical world at certain significant scales is still dozens of orders of magnitude away is interesting and relevant, but the conclusion that therefore brain simulation is impossible and the reasonably-inferred conclusion that we can never understand these other large structures is logically invalid, due to a strawman view of what "brain simulation is" and due to a very peculiar and not-widely-shared implicit definition of "understanding".
[1]: Note I'm not saying anything about the simulation corresponding to reality today, I'm strictly referring to the terabytes of data the simulation itself can produce on its own terms.